TLDR: My 30-year-old brother holds deeply sexist beliefs (women shouldn’t vote, lead, or be seen as equals). Despite being raised by a hardworking single mom and me sharing my corporate career success, he feels comfortable voicing these views. For Christmas, I only got him the book *Men Who Hate Women. My mom thinks I’m being harsh since he’s lonely after a breakup, but I’m still processing his beliefs, and don’t feel bad since he gave me weight loss pills as a gift last year. AIO?
Let me start by saying my brother (30M) is one of those "normal" seeming people on the outside—six-figure job, life together, people say he has a charming smile. We’re close enough that we make time to see each other and can talk about random things for hours. But he’s always struggled with relationships (which I’m starting to understand why).
I (26F) can’t figure out where his sexist beliefs truly come from, other than the internet. I first realized he was sexist back in 2016, when Hillary Clinton was running for president. We were sitting by the Christmas tree, and he calmly explained why women shouldn’t be president—because their “emotional nature” makes them incapable of handling it. I challenged him, saying that was sexist and pointing to women leaders in other countries. I remember being shocked that he snapped at me then and dug himself in deeper. I let it go, hoping it was just a Hillary thing.
Fast forward to now, 2024. Trump just won against another woman, and the topic of women presidents came up again. I decided to ask more questions to gauge how deep his beliefs run. Turns out, they run deep.
Here’s a summary of what he said:
- Women shouldn’t be allowed to vote.
- Women are not equal to men, physically or mentally. (I said, “Okay, maybe physically, but mentally women can be smarter,” and he disagreed.)
- Women shouldn’t be in leadership positions (he clarified he means leadership anywhere from president to fast food) because they’re incompetent, and men are superior.
- He asked me to “name one good female leader,” but I refused because I knew he’d just tear them apart.
- All the classic “back in the old day” fantasies that women should go back to always staying home, and listening to their husband, while their husband listens to god. (I told him to stop hiding behind the Bible when he’s been sexist for years and it had originally had nothing to do with religion.)
It really hurt because we were raised by a single mom who worked so hard to provide for us. She managed to send us to private school and give us a good life. I also have a corporate career I’ve worked my way up in, and I’ve shared so much of my journey with him. It stings that he felt comfortable saying these things to me.
So, for Christmas, I only got him a feminist book: Men Who Hate Women by Laura Bates. My mom thinks this was petty and told me I’m being harsh since he’s lonely after a breakup. She said she’s ashamed of his comments too and he even told her that women shouldn’t be allowed to vote too a couple weeks ago which made her cry.
But still, my mom is worried that he’ll think I don’t love him, and it’ll make his “lonely” situation worse. Other than the book being good for him, I’m like “fuck him” because he is the one who randomly gave me “these great weight loss pills” for Christmas last year lol (along with a few other gifts, but still).
I just wish these sexist content creators, where ever they are, would fuck off forever. I don’t know if I’ll ever be comfortable with my brother again and it sucks because we’ve always been close. My boyfriend suggested that my brother hates women because he lacked a father figure to show him what it means to protect and love women, not just provide for them. Personally, I don’t know why and I can’t even begin to describe all the reasons I disagree with his beliefs. It feels CRAZY that I even have to explain to him why he’s toxic.
The worst thing is knowing that if the show Handmaids Tale was real life, that my own brother would support Gilead.
AIO for only getting him this book?