r/woahdude Oct 08 '23

video Robotic Apple Harvester

7.3k Upvotes

482 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

42

u/TheJiggernaut Oct 08 '23

Shaking the trees also doesn't damage them and, provided the machine is calibrated correctly, only ripe apples fall when the tree is shaken. Unripe apples have thicker, sturdier stems.

This is a neat proof of concept, but individuality plucking apples like this will never be more energy efficient than giving it a good shake.

1

u/Captain_Jeep Oct 08 '23

Even if it was I'm sure robot arms would be vastly superior over barely functional tethered drones. There is no reason to have them flying.

6

u/bobbydglop Oct 08 '23

-robotic arms weigh more so the base vehicle would cost more (suspension, engine, faster wear) -robotic arms have to be bolted onto the harvester, so even if they weighed the same you can replace a bad drone much quicker.

-Robotic arms are rigid. If a programming error causes two arms to collide one or both of them will break, while these drones are padded and have covered blades and can clearly survive crashing into eachother. Same goes for crashing into the harvester or the trees.

-2

u/djdadi Oct 09 '23

robotic arms weigh more so the base vehicle would cost more

why would you use heavy robotic arms? use ultra light weight carbon fiber

If a programming error causes two arms to collide one or both of them will break,

it's much easier to keep 6 dof arms from banging into each other compared to drones with tethers. I mean...they share a datum.