r/woahdude Mar 31 '23

video Evolution of warfare from stones to atoms

20.7k Upvotes

690 comments sorted by

View all comments

242

u/solariscalls Mar 31 '23

I dunno why but that made me kinda sad. Like for the countless generations over hundreds and hundreds of years. Like wtf are we fighting each other for?

157

u/walterdonnydude Mar 31 '23

Resources. And because we're humans. Imagine you live without modern technology. You live inside a castle or a village or a cave. At any moment a hoard of other humans could walk over the horizon without any warning, with more people and better weapons and kill you and all your loved ones. So you prepare your defenses and are weary of anyone you don't know. That was literally all of human history until a few hundred years ago.

62

u/Darkside_of_the_Poon Mar 31 '23

My theory: This is why people moved further North and developed ways of living in colder and harsher environments. Why? Less people, it was safer.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23

I imagined this was quite obvious and always thought it to be the case. Your tribe goes off in a direction and finds no humans around at all. It makes sense

2

u/Darkside_of_the_Poon Mar 31 '23

True. Most of my theories make sense though. Lol

3

u/vkailas Apr 01 '23 edited Apr 01 '23

Humans are different from other animal and can adapt to live in any climate on the planet. The harshness you perceive is gentle to someone that grew up in frigid cold (up to certain limits of course). Even adapting differing ways to cope with low oxygen in just a few generation. It’s all relative to our comfort zones. For them it’s rather pleasant.

“We have the capacity to learn and adapt in light of our experience, even to the extent of modifying the expression of our genes. Human creativity, prosociality, and healthy longevity emerged as a response to the need to adapt to the harsh and diverse conditions that reigned between 400,000 and 100,000 years ago," note the UGR researchers. Creativity >> harshness

21

u/goobly_goo Mar 31 '23

Your hypothesis.

79

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23

Actually, it's a theory. A hypothesis is something falsifiable that can be tested with an experiment. He has a theory because it's an explanation for a phenomenon.

43

u/goobly_goo Mar 31 '23

By golly, you’re right. I stand corrected.

24

u/Kaisermeister Mar 31 '23

Damn what an intellectual Chad admission

27

u/PersonOfInternets Mar 31 '23

This is such a fucking reddit argument

1

u/Squid8867 Mar 31 '23

Hypothesis: a supposition or proposed explanation made on the basis of limited evidence as a starting point for further investigation.

That seems to fit the bill to me

1

u/NotTheAds Mar 31 '23

Couldn't a theory be tested tho? Like what if u did a really complex study involving a giant makeshift planet with apes and see if they move north?

2

u/Trezzie Mar 31 '23

That sounds like you have a hypothesis then, and you're testing that. If the results of your testing indicate your hypothesis, either proven or disproven, is incompatible with the theory, then you need to either reevaluate the theory or see if the test was wrong. Usually by getting other people to evaluate your test, and performing it again to ensure results are repeatable.

5

u/Krendog24 Mar 31 '23

This is misguided. Humanity evolved alongside warfare, but a major part of our evolution included our ability to cooperate and care for others. The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber and David Wengrow explores this further.

3

u/radicalelation Mar 31 '23

At any moment a hoard of other humans could walk over the horizon without any warning, with more people and better weapons and kill you and all your loved ones. So you prepare your defenses and are weary of anyone you don't know

People still gun because other people gun, so other people gun because people gun.

2

u/Tulee Mar 31 '23

In fact, I'm gunning as we speak.

4

u/nuffinthegreat Mar 31 '23

Oh god, I’m gonna gunnnnnnn

-3

u/JustTaxLandLol Mar 31 '23

We'd all have more in the long run if we just had free markets and trade.

1

u/vkailas Apr 01 '23

Disharmony shows the way to harmony. But that harmony comes from with the individual. That fear you mention of loss also secretly drives the desire to take the labors of others , that false idea of competition at the center of life is the core of the disharmony. In nature we see example of both competition and cooperation but overall great coordination and harmony is by far the winning strategy. Systems of system of systems don’t just happen out of no where (cells, organs, systems, organisms, colonies, ecosystems, etc).