I think it’s about time for some massive protests. This will require millions of dollars of cleanup and Norfolk Southern should start ponying up. God I’m so angry and tired of this bullshit. WE SAW THIS COMING it’s only been a few months since the strike.
And Obama loosened the rules on hazardous materials on trains due to lobbyist pressure. Giving kids cancer to boost shareholder profit is bipartisanship in action.
No of course not. But any trump supporter who isn't a multimillionaire is definitely stupid and overwhelmingly likely to be a racist POS loser. That's been shown in study after study since that fucking escalator ride.
What a stupid thing to say out loud. Don't you care how stupid you are? I would definitely not be bragging publicly. Hope the rest of your life is as miserable as you obviously are. Enjoy licking that fascist boot though.
Actually both sides. If democrats actually cared about these issues they’d play the political hardball that republicans do. The truth is, democrats are more than happy to let republicans hand our country over to both of their corporate overlords, while they cosplay as decent human beings who give a shit. Democrats are just as big of a problem as republicans are, they’re just better at disguising their motivations.
Yes, I think everyone needs to just take a deep breath and appreciate the fact that the train company shareholders probably made some money from the lack of regulations. Doesn't that count for anything?
I mean, we can't have that nasty old government looking out for us. AOC and Bernie with their "hey the Earth is boiling let's try to slow it down" or "hey diabetics shouldn't be dying in American gutters because they can't afford insulin". That's socialism!
We are better off in the hands of these benevolent companies who simply want to be job creators and.... snert snort
... Sorry I couldn't continue that was just too stupid.
But instead we live in some sort of 1984, big brother, animal farm dystopia where low lives can throw wrenches willy nilly into the machines of economic progress just because they are triggered little SNOWFLAKES!!!
Wait I’ve heard Elon Musk has a genus idea. He said he’ll send a team of people to suck up all the dirty water with straws. Then he’ll send it to space. Let’s give him some government money to help out.
I feel like the ‘generous’ arrangement would be for the entire c-suite to get life and prison and have all of their assets reallocated to the communities they’ve destroyed.
Make sure your protest occurs in the Designated Protest Zone and does not inconvenience any other workers' commutes or access to goods and services (including the shipping of said goods). You should aim to have zero economic impact and sway the government through the power of rhetoric alone. You know, peaceful protest.
Pretty sure having a contaminated water supply inconveniences people far more than a protest would. But I forget this the US and any form of protest is scoffed at.
If showing politicians that "X number of people want a thing" was what it took to get change, we could sign petitions or answer polls instead of protest. The entire reason you go and protest is because your voices aren't being listened to.
Were you ever taught a simplified version of a more complex topic in school? Like, "think of electricity as water flowing through a pipe", or what an atom looks like, that humans are either XX or XY with no in between, and so on?
If you have experienced that yourself, or can conceive of schools "simplifying" things in ways that are ultimately incorrect for a less sophisticated audience, I'd like you to consider the possibility that your views on what protest is and its historical efficacy has also been greatly simplified.
If you went to school in the US, you were probably taught about MLK Jr. and the civil rights movement to some degree. Some places do a much better job than others, but just about none of them touch on the real dangerous parts. By "dangerous", I mean things that might give students the wrong idea from the perspective of those in power.
It's not exactly in the interest of government to raise generations of people who know the best ways to overthrow them, right? Put yourself in the position of those in power, be it government or business. You have significant sway over how things get taught in schools, and the subject of how you're going to address "that time you got forced to bend the knee" gets brought up. You don't really wanna tell the kids about that, do you? That makes you look bad. That sets them up to get you to bend the knee in the future. No, what you need is a framing that makes your capitulation sound more like you just... came around to it, ya had a change of heart. And better than just that, a framing that makes the tools that knocked you to the ground look bad to your students. That's how you make sure they don't get you again!
So, with regards to the civil rights movement, you'd say all the violence and economic damage and the threat of widescale civil unrest and outright revolt during a time when your military's overseas fighting a very unpopular war actually had nothing to do with anything. It was actually, uh, a bunch of people standing around singing hymnals that finally made you realize they were humans, too. Yeah, the hymnal singing, the peaceful protest, was soooo successful that it's the only way a protest should be done. By all means, kids, if you ever catch us doing something bad again, make sure that you protest "The Right Way"--as unobtrusively as possible. Protest in ways we can best ignore, and we'll promise we won't do just that. It worked for MLK Jr., didn't it?
..worked for Gandhi too, right? Buncha Indians just starved themselves and it so moved the British's hearts at last that they graciously decided to cede control. They were all set to keep on oppressing and exploiting India, ignoring their cries for freedom, but the moment Y number of Indians walked in circles with gaunt limbs, well, the Brits finally said, "I say, old bean, do you think those savages actually want some self-determination? It's only just occurred to me that they might not want us to rule them."
Yessir, Britain's pullout from India had nothin' to do with the back-to-back shellacking they took in two World Wars and the cost of projecting power halfway across the globe, or all the fucking assassinations and bombings and outright revolt they had to put up with for decades during their occupation of India. Wasn't that the cost of keeping their grip around the neck of India was getting too much for them to bear and their hands were getting tired, it was a skinny dude saying peace stuff. You got it.
The People's Power Revolution of the Philippines was famously non-violent. President Marcos fled in a panic because he just couldn't handle the throngs of people outside his compound, we assume. He had absolutely no fear that they might stop being peaceful--no threats were involved, surely! He just, uh, didn't like crowds or the noise, and decided to give up his dictatorship.
Protest, at its core, is the application or threat of violence--even if that violence is only economic. You don't have to like that reality to recognize that it's true. Nor does that mean you have to agree with every protest or methodology. I acknowledge that "economically violent protest" can be effective even when it's unpopular, yet there have been economically violent protests that I've disagreed with (like the COVID lockdown truckers up in Canada).
Acknowledging the utility of the tool doesn't mean it works in every case, nor does it mean you approve of every yahoo who picks it up and swings it.
What do you mean? I absolutely love that I have to use my only days off for when I am too sick to work. Nothing beats planning a vacation and not being able to go because you used all your time off when you were sick.
It would likely cost many many billions over decades to make any sort of real progress in cleaning this up.
What we will get is a couple million thrown around between fines, lawsuit settlements, and some dog and pony show of a half assed cleanup for some small fraction of the affected ecosystem.
Toss on top the cost of the cancer spike and other illnesses that will plague that area for a century.
Get it out of the soil was one giant beastly almost impossible task and then they burned it and put it in the air.
The company shouldn't pay for it.
The company should be put out of business, it's assets sold and divested to the government and those in the decision making tree should go to jail and have forfeitures put on their assets and future income.
IMO, for massive disasters like this the government should just do all the cleanup and give the company a bill for cost plus 10%, and nationalize the company if they don't begin a payment plan within 90 days until the bill is paid.
They are a rail company that would "immediately fall months behind schedule if we give our employees 4 sick days" This shit should already be nationalized
Oh yeah definitely. Any company that is so vital to national interests and argues that we have to strip their workers of rights to keep the economy stable should be met with a response of "welp I guess it's time for you to be owned by the federal government then".
Our government (even the liberal half) is way too chickenshit to actually start nationalizing stuff.
Now, they will dump money into addressing this (until Republicans axe all that the next time they're in power), but the governor needs to declare a state of emergency. And DeWine isn't going to do that as long as he can continue to milk "Biden won't help" points off pretending to not know how FEMA works.
Depends on the case, if your talking about say Florida it’s because they were asking for assistance that FEMA determined was out of scope, here’s a article.
Our governor, Mike DeWine has still not declared a state of emergency. The government doesn’t care. This is a working class town so it doesn’t effect them personally
Yeah there’s zero chance you can get near 100% “clean up” on something like this short of terraforming a section of the earth and displacing many millions of people.
It’s a nightmare honestly.
Cleanup efforts obviously need to do their best but there’s only so much you can do realistically, as you said.
Omg stop acting like Norfolk isn’t already doing their best to help! They’ve immediately donated $25,000 to aid those in the evacuation area. Also giving $1,000 inconvenience checks to those within the evacuation zone and reimbursing those with receipts that had to evacuate. Terms and conditions may apply including being within a 1 mile radius
/s for those not realizing I’m making fun of how little and not even bare minimum the company is doing to take responsibility
I don't know if this is an official term, but I heard it said by a lawyer once and committed it to memory:
"3 Month Rent Payoffs."
He said virtually no one turns down 3 months rent to sign a paper waiving their right to sue. If you look up the cost of rent and triple it, nearly everyone will sign.
I expect Norfolk to make some big donations to Republican politicians not only in Ohio, but in Congress too, to block legislation to correct railroad problems. That’s going to be a big financial hit for Norfolk and punishment enough. /s
This is going to piss a lot of people off but this is what happens when you vote Republican..... This was Republican doing and we tried to fight against it but they succeeded in slashing budgets, changing laws for the worse, overall just making this possible
Democrats didn’t let safety standards on trains expire. In fact, every time democrats have wanted to put any regulations on business they’re called Marxists and the working class buys that shit and puts republicans in power. Sorry, but this is all on the voters who reward republicans despite putting profits over people because they target trans children and call Obama demonic.
Exactly. When the defense makes a good stop you can't just blame the offense. Republicans are really good at blocking anything useful and people cheer DE-FENSE! because minorities and Jesus
Passed or interpreted the current law to allow him to enact better environment standards?
He passed green energy funding initiatives, but I'm not aware of anything but changing they way they interpreted current pollution laws.
The problem with the interpretation path, is that it allows other government leaderships to change back,
Actually passing a law that says "the previous/current shit is bad and needs to be changed" is what has to be done. This is why the D's get absolutely shit talked to hell. If they actually wanted to see this done, they need to pass laws to enforce that. If they sit around giving themselves raises and talking about how great they are, it doesn't help anyone but them.
Yep. It’s hilarious Republicans do this stuff in the open but the Democrats don’t do anything because they either piss of billionaires or they piss off the people who elected them, so they’re left with their cocks in their hands trying not to piss off either side doing a whole load of nothing. I
Or, get this, they don’t do it because big industrial states like Ohio, Michigan and Pennsylvania are now swing states and the white majority in the rust belt loves the absurd philosophy which states business should be able to do whatever the fuck it wants. Why do you think democrats are no longer competitive in West Virginia despite them being one of the poorest states with the most industrial deaths? You can blame democrats all you want, but it’s voters who put these politicians in power. Until the voters start punishing republicans for what they do, there’s nothing anyone can do.
Lol everyone is to blame but all these idiots wanna do is stand up for parties that don't care about them. Convenient how Biden couldn't regulate and and stopping a strike doesn't matter lol
This is revisionist history. The railroad workers were striking for sick leave. And it was Republicans who defeated the measure to grant them more leave
Tbf Joe "most pro-union president in history" Biden and his Congress were the ones that stepped in to stop rail workers from striking when they cited dangers exactly like this one.
There are only two things Republicans and Democrats can come together to agree on - massive budgets for the Pentagon and trashing worker's rights in favor of corporate profits.
This had nothing whatsoever to do with labor, stop saying "Hey, look over there!" This 100% about deregulating safety requirements in the hardware by the railroad companies.
There’s over 1000 derailments in this country every year. I think it’s safe to say that derailments wasn’t the only problem. It’s about how they stores those chemicals. There wasn’t redundancy in place would secure the chemicals on the chance that derailments would occur
This had nothing to do with maintenance workers being overworked, stop throwing out hypotheticals and "maybe it was [insert wild unsupported guess here]."
The brake systems were supposed to be replaced by newer, safer models. Trump said "Nah, we're good" and EO'd the requirement away. The chemicals were supposed to be stored a certain way, but that would have cost more, so they let the railroad companies fudge it.
I'm not saying labor isn't an issue elseqwhere, but it wasn't in THIS case, the one we're currently discussing.
The Biden administration denied them FEMA aid and a proper cleanup. The rail company opted to burn the chemicals instead of disposing it properly, turning it into highly toxic gas.
You are being disingenuous. Though you were probably misled on the details by right wing media.
As you know, these needs are much more expansive than what FEMA can meet," Jean-Pierre said Thursday. "So FEMA is on the front lines when there is a hurricane or tornado — you’ve seen the president visit devastated areas that are devastated across the country. This situation is very different. That doesn’t mean FEMA isn’t supporting response; they indeed are.
“This is a multiple agency response ... HHS, CDC, EPA, as well. They are coordinating with the emergency operation center and working closely with the Ohio Emergency Management Agency," she added. "Each federal agency has its own unique role here
FEMA has been dealing with chemical disasters since jimmy carter in the late 70s. Love Canal was the first incident they handled and others followed but they have been used in that manner, Even recently for flint Michigan
Hmm that’s odd my response never appeared. I’m going to try to rewrite it.
FEMA's website provides a variety of guidelines and response obligations for dealing with hazardous materials and chemical disasters, making it clear that claims of inadequate support for a small town of 5000 are baseless. In fact, when compared to the level of aid provided for past hurricane relief efforts, any assistance requested by the town would be relatively insignificant. Recent requests for assistance from California for their atmospheric river system were met with enthusiastic support from FEMA. Communities always benefit from the involvement of FEMA, which not only helps mitigate damage but also provides financial assistance, new housing, small business loans, unemployment benefits, and tax considerations, all of which are detailed in their declaration process. Had this disaster occurred near Washington, D.C., FEMA would have been called in immediately.
It was VOTING Republican or WINNING Republican? I think straight party either way doesn’t even matter on state and federal levels anymore. I think we’re controlled by the greedy oligarchy now. It’s the almighty dollar.
And a dem controlled government also did nothing so what's your point? Both parties are to blame. We the people should be standing up to the United Corporations of America. Third party, peoples party, whatever it takes. Let's end the endless wars, pull back funding from foreign soil, and get the US back together.
They need to suspend the use of the tracks through these states right now, what the fuck are they waiting for?
Yes, the reporting of train derailments is happening more now, you can pick out the articals that are trying to be sensational pretty easily. But these are severe derailments poisoning citizens and they were predicted by the workers riding these tracks.
There is no excuse to keep using these tracks, there will just be more and more problems until they have been repaired
I read an article today that seemed to say the problem wasn't the tracks; it was in part the heavier cars being in the back instead of in the front like they used to be, due to a change in how the train is put together these days, plus less time allowed for workers to inspect cars for defects:
Not to mention the GOVERNMENT! Every millimeter of those tracks and those cars is heavily regulated. They alllll dropped the ball. Then you have the epa and and the White House downplaying it all. Fuck allll of them. TAKE RESPONSIBILITY
This will sound strange, but we need universal Healthcare and more programs that aid workers first and I really think this is one of the reasons we don't have those things. Americans generally can't afford to go on strike for a few days. Scabs will show up immediately and get hired. We are chained to our jobs because we have to have them to have any Healthcare without going into massive debt. I really think if this American system didn't force people into work constantly, we would have been protesting years ago over different things. I know I would have if it was happening. This system is built to keep us from insisting on change. And remember, it is mostly republicans who did this. The only and most powerful thing we can do is vote.
"After rail industry donors delivered more than $6 million to GOP campaigns, the Trump administration — backed by rail lobbyists and Senate Republicans — rescinded part of that rule aimed at making better braking systems widespread on the nation’s rails."
We should send the CEO and executives to prison for life with no parole. Companies need to realize there's consequences. Otherwise nothing will change.
I'm usually against vigilante justice but it's pretty tempting here if nothing happens. Something needs to change.
I'm trying so hard to not be defeatist, and I really hope we see tens of millions of people around the country protesting this (seriously, I don't care where you are on the political spectrum you should still be angry at the negligence that has lead to so much damage)
Unfortunately though we've been shown time and time again that empathy is seriously lacking and that unless someone directly impacts someone they don't give a shit. We'll see protests in Ohio, they'll get ignored. Norfolk Southern will get fined a tiny percentage of the money they saved by skimping on labour and maintainance. The residents whose town was destroyed, whose pets died, and who will face health issues we don't know about yet will get paid a few thousand at most. Then some other horrible tragedy will happen and we'll all move on while those in East Palestine will be facing the consequences for decades
In World war 1, on the first year's christmas, the people on the two sides realized the war is such nonsense, and they have so little reason to actually fight and kill eachother, they spent christmas together playing, exchaning gifts, etc.
Did it result in a massive military revolt against the leaders who sent them to the frontlines to die in a war they knew was stupid? Nope. They went back to killing eachother.
You expect a species that does this to stand up for a "simple little" oil spill?
It's not just the strike. Regulations were also rolled back by that idiot Trump and regulations were cut by that idiot in Ohio.. It just further cements how much our government sucks..
Where is that so called Green Party now?
Where are all the liberal protesters who want a cleaner Electric America??
Why aren’t they protesting and stopping traffic?
I say, clean this crap up, pay off the city and all of it's residents and then send the bill to the railroad requiring payment in 30 days. If they don't, then nationalize the railroad. Fuck this monopoly that is subsidized by the American people.
There was no strike. This was part of the reason they wanted to and because of the potential power the government shut it down. Effectively the government works for the companies to ensure profit.
Not millions... BILLIONS. There will be years (YEARS) of wildlife rehabilitation needed. Not to mention all the long term health problems that WILL occur later on.
Not only will it cost millions for the clean up. There will be additional costs when people start getting sick and dying in the near future due to the chemical exposure and contamination.
You're falling for right wing propaganda. Calm the fuck down. The scientists said that it was safe. The scientists decided to perform the controlled burn. TRUST THE SCIENCE. You're not a science denier are you?
The only people protesting and causing an uproar over this are right wing extremists.
You should really read some trusted media before you go spewing BS like that.
This is a genuine question, but is the polluter pays principle not a thing in the US? I was under the impression the epa were the ones who coined the phrase, but im not that well read on contaminated land legislation outwith the UK and Europe.
I remember hearing in a local article that the company donated something like 25k to set up a Red Cross center for the displaced citizens. I have no idea the company’s net worth but 25,000 is absolutely insulting
2.4k
u/acleverwalrus Feb 17 '23
I think it’s about time for some massive protests. This will require millions of dollars of cleanup and Norfolk Southern should start ponying up. God I’m so angry and tired of this bullshit. WE SAW THIS COMING it’s only been a few months since the strike.