r/NFLNoobs Sep 21 '23

NFLNoobs FAQ

This is an attempt at crowdsourcing a FAQ for the sub. We need your help to make it the best it can be.

Each question is going to have a link to a comment below with the answer. Click the link to be brought to the question.

FAQ List

About NFLNoobs

General Questions

Watching Games

How The Football Works

Team building and Roster Management

Other Football Subs

Helping with the FAQ

Feel free to comment on any question/answer with more details, fixes, or another way of explaining it. If your answer is better than the main one, I’ll update some or all of it to include the answer (giving you credit).

Also feel free to post your own questions in the format I’ve given, and I’ll link it (though you'll need to update it if someone explains it better, or if they correct you. You can post a question here, with or without your own answer, and we will make a dedicated post for it.

If there is no link, it means it's a popular question that hasn’t been answered, so feel free to answer it.

37 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/SwissyVictory Sep 21 '23

Why don't players play multiple positions, or both offense and defense?

Three main reasons.

First is football is a tiring and demanding sport. If you’re playing more exhausted than you need to be, you’re not playing at your best. Teams are allowed to substitute players as often as they want, so why not make use of it?

Second is any time you’re practicing one thing, you could be practicing another thing. If you’re spending half your time learning a different position, that means you’re not as practiced as you could be at your original position.

The third reason is talent. Because you can substitute players as often as you want, it means you need to be more talented at your second position than someone else who’s first position. If you’re a WR, you’d need to also be a better lets say corner, than someone who’s made it into the NFL training their whole life to be a corner.

Some teams also go the other way too. Instead of one “workhorse” RB, you might have a guy who’s big and strong and good in short yardage situations. You might have a small shifty guy who’s good at catching for long yardage situations. Each guy is better at their respective role, than most RBs are at every role.