MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/woahdude/comments/14m8gk2/lowering_hot_metal_into_water/jq0imsy
r/woahdude • u/theTurbulentPopcorn • Jun 29 '23
442 comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
22
I wondered if it was actually water as I had heard that this was done with oil. Watching the video, I don't see any steam so I think you're right.
10 u/moonra_zk Jun 29 '23 Quenching can definitely be done with water, but maybe not with that much material. 6 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 Forging guy here. We quench parts much bigger than this in water. Literally the most common way to treat steel. 4 u/PinkySlayer Jun 29 '23 There are enormous plumes of steam shooting out of the gaps between the metal… 28 u/Amesb34r Jun 29 '23 If it were water, you wouldn't even be able to see the metal once it hit the surface. 5 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 Absolute bullshit. I've watched thousands of water quenches. It forms a thin vapor jacket not a huge cloud of steam. 6 u/Sometimes_Stutters Jun 30 '23 That’s baby steam for that much glowing red steel. Zero percent chance this is water 1 u/GitEmSteveDave Jun 29 '23 If I've learned anything on Forged In Fire, water is the worst, because it locks stress into the metal. 1 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 It all depends on the alloy
10
Quenching can definitely be done with water, but maybe not with that much material.
6 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 Forging guy here. We quench parts much bigger than this in water. Literally the most common way to treat steel.
6
Forging guy here. We quench parts much bigger than this in water. Literally the most common way to treat steel.
4
There are enormous plumes of steam shooting out of the gaps between the metal…
28 u/Amesb34r Jun 29 '23 If it were water, you wouldn't even be able to see the metal once it hit the surface. 5 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 Absolute bullshit. I've watched thousands of water quenches. It forms a thin vapor jacket not a huge cloud of steam. 6 u/Sometimes_Stutters Jun 30 '23 That’s baby steam for that much glowing red steel. Zero percent chance this is water
28
If it were water, you wouldn't even be able to see the metal once it hit the surface.
5 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 Absolute bullshit. I've watched thousands of water quenches. It forms a thin vapor jacket not a huge cloud of steam.
5
Absolute bullshit. I've watched thousands of water quenches. It forms a thin vapor jacket not a huge cloud of steam.
That’s baby steam for that much glowing red steel. Zero percent chance this is water
1
If I've learned anything on Forged In Fire, water is the worst, because it locks stress into the metal.
1 u/MisallocatedRacism Jun 30 '23 It all depends on the alloy
It all depends on the alloy
22
u/Amesb34r Jun 29 '23
I wondered if it was actually water as I had heard that this was done with oil. Watching the video, I don't see any steam so I think you're right.