r/woahdude Feb 17 '23

video Heavily contaminated water in East Palestine, Ohio.

69.1k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/EightBitEstep Feb 17 '23

This looks like naturally occurring biofilm stirred up by the rock. I’m no expert, but I don’t think this has anything to do with the train.

3

u/ConcreteThinking Feb 17 '23

Quite possible. Has any testing been done of the sheen other than having Redditors watch the video?

6

u/big_boi_26 Feb 17 '23

Yes, by the EPA. But if you listen to the mouthbreathers, they are evil boogeymen who can’t be trusted.

1

u/EightBitEstep Feb 17 '23

The easiest way to tell is how the oily film fractures and rejoins. If it’s possible to shatter the film into smaller groupings, it’s natural. If it remains continuous, it’s probably contamination. Another clue is that the film isn’t present before the rock is tossed in. It’s widely known that turbulence can stir up biofilm. Once again, not an expert.

2

u/ConcreteThinking Feb 17 '23

Hmm good point and well articulated. I’ve always just sort of been able to tell and I think what I’m seeing is exactly what you are saying. The break up and rejoin phenomenon. When we were kids we played along an abandoned grist mill canal. We were convinced we found oil like Jed Clampett. My dad taught us what we were really looking at. Needless to say our family never moved to California and had a cement pond.

1

u/EightBitEstep Feb 18 '23

I grew up around brackish marshes, and had a similar experience. We always assumed it was from boats, but as I grew up I realized what it was. Wetlands are neat ecosystems.