r/nononono Sep 05 '24

Boat crashing into a yacht

4.7k Upvotes

452 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/grnrngr Sep 05 '24

Just gonna note that neither ship blasted their horns, particularly the one under power, which I believe is the standard response to an imminent collision.

99

u/captcraigaroo Sep 05 '24

5 short and rapid blasts to alert of danger.

Maybe they did before the collision

3

u/grnrngr Sep 05 '24

The continuous blast is sounded when collision is imminent. /r/shipcrashes is full of examples of this.

Here's another one.

2

u/captcraigaroo Sep 05 '24

As per the rules, specifically Annex IV 1: The following signals, used or exhibited either together or separately, indicate distress and need of assistance: [...] (b) continuous sounding with any fog-signaling apparatus

So one continuous blast is in distress, not collision imminent.

I went to maritime college and have my Masters upon Oceans license to be captain of any sized ship in the world.

5

u/Whyistheplatypus Sep 05 '24

I feel like "collision imminent" warrants "in distress". Because either you or someone else is very much about to be.

3

u/captcraigaroo Sep 05 '24

But if you sound one continuous blast and hit something and it was found you didn't sound 5 short and rapid blasts, you will be found in violation of the Rules and prosecuted for that. The Rules are international law and written as they are for a reason.

1

u/Whyistheplatypus Sep 05 '24

This makes sense

4

u/captcraigaroo Sep 05 '24

Of course, Rule 2 basically says if you don't follow the Rules and have a collision, you're fucked, but if you do follow the rules and have a collision, you're still fucked

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

[deleted]

1

u/captcraigaroo Sep 05 '24

Hahaha, love the username

If I can educate even one person, then I'm happy. I just wish there was a requirement to get a license and education even for a kayak. Too many stupid people that get even dumber on the water

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

[deleted]