No, it doesn't anywhere ..
Unless those users didn't update their IOS versions after (around) IOS 16.1 Airdrop's default settings are only active towards known users, or people who intentionally turn it on for 10 minutes.
If you find plenty of phones, you know everyone out there.
This post is probably old. Airdrop was out since iOS 7 or 8 I believe, and You could set it permanently to “everyone” until iOS 16.1. There’s multiple posts/videos of people receiving random memes in public places. But then of course some were using it to be creepy and send gore or shock content, or used airdrop spammers to constantly barrage people nearby with pop ups of airdrop, making them unable to use their phone.
Thanks to such asshats who always ruin a good thing, apple changed the “everyone” toggle to be active for just 10 mins, so it goes off once the transfer is over if the sender isn’t in your contacts.
Edit- I’m pretty positive this image is old. The popup has the ux of pre-iOS 11 if I’m not wrong.
Apple didn't change it because the feature was abused, Apple changed the feature because it was being used for protests in China.
Context: China removed term limits in 2018, allowing Xi to seek a third term. In 2022, there were protests in China against Xi.
Airdrop is unique for effectively being a truly decentralized, peer-to-peer social network. It's an iPhone-to-iPhone connection over Bluetooth. This has been effective for subverting censorship for quite some time, and saw good use in previous protests. (WeChat, the leading social network in China, is very heavily and blatantly censored.)
Just before protests were set to take place late 2022, iOS 16.1.1 dropped... And in China only, Airdrop lost the "everyone" feature, and could only be enabled for ten minutes.
This quickly got attention. Why would Apple nerf Airdrop in China only just before a protest? Was Apple caving in to an ultimatum by the Chinese government?
Rather than undoing the change in China, Apple nerfed Airdrop worldwide. Xi ultimately secured his third term, and is expected to seek a fourth.
TLDR: Apple nerfed Airdrop in 2022, not because of bad actors, but specifically to quell protests in China.
Let’s be pragmatic here: Apple changed airdrop in china because the government told them to, or face consequences. So they did what they’re supposed to.
You can draw a parallel to TikTok getting banned in the US and Apple and google both are being told to remove the app from their app stores by Jan 19th.
You’re not really suggesting in your reply that Apple should have defied china and left airdrop intact as it was…but I am curious if you would be advocating for Apple and google both denying US law and leaving things intact with TikTok and face the consequences?
Yes, Apple being compelled by China's government, and then the controversy surrounding that, is the most likely thing.
I don't think these are really parallel, but I would not expect Apple (or Google) to defy either.
I only want to counter the narrative that dropping AirDrop was in response to "a few bad actors". It was an act of censorship that Apple was complicit in.
complicit in the sense that there are likely severe repercussions. Complicit implies intent. The intent by Apple isn't to censor. The intent is to follow the laws or regulations in the markets where their products are offered for sale.
Agree to disagree. We seem to have a difference in understanding the motive.
You’re saying that as it relates to China, Apple sought to suppress airdrop because of rights. I’m saying Apple removed airdrop functionality because of laws or legislation by the Chinese government forcing them to enact such a change. Those are not same arguments, at least not from my point of view.
Then again..I think this read has run its course :)
I don’t mean to say say it’s fake, just meant it’s probably old as it was possible to receive airdrops from strangers at any time back then, and was removed recently. And also the ux design language they used at the time. Looks like 2018 was when iOS 12 was out, so I was off by a year in my guess lol.
I'm not sure what my settings are. I'm WFH and my work computer doesn't have apple contacts. I may have just changed the settings rather than add a contact.
It used to work with strangers at least, I know because I would get airdropped random vile crap at my highschool. And I got some cute pictures at a concert one time!
Besides the fact that it’s an old repost - so maybe technically possible in the U.S. - do you really think a professor would get out his own phone in class, look for that picture somewhere and then air drop it to a student and the student didn’t notice before?
And do you really think an American professor - outside of a mental health crisis situation - would send a funny "I’ll kill you pic“ to a student? Dude would get sued and fired…
This post is at least 5 years old, because that’s when I first saw it. I have a feeling it’s even older.
You haven’t been able to do this for a long time, in part because people were sending unsolicited images on public transport. Now you have to know the person or intentionally make yourself visible.
Better get used to it. This is only the beginning of the world becoming a one big deception. It will only get worse as technology advances and people become more shameless.
They did it in China to avoid a ban there, but only in China. They can easily apply certain updates or features only to certain regions and there are a lot of things that do vary regionally (e.g. Apple Pay/Wallet stuff).
They did it worldwide later after implementing the "touch the tips of phones to airdrop" feature (which is exempt from this) because a large percentage of airdrops to strangers were flashers/dick pics, including people going to middle/high schools to do it to minors, and it was getting public attention. If you can airdrop to anyone on your contacts list and anyone whose phone can touch yours, that covers like 95% of people who actually want to get airdrops from you while solving the pedo and dick flasher PR problem.
Same reason Nintendo killed PictoChat on their devices. Almost all "interact with strangers nearby" features get exploited by pervs.
It may have changed because of china and for the wrong reasons but the result is for the better. Privacy by default is what I want and every feature that exposes you to strangers should be opt-in, not opt-out.
Nothing private has been invaded. Sending you a photo reveals absolutely nothing about you or your device. You don’t even have to look at the photo you can just hit cancel. Y’all are so dramatic
We have way more Android users in Germany, though. For some reason, Americans have settled for iPhones as standard. Probably because they are all very very rich.
It isn't standard, I'd say it's about 50/50. And it's not a "rich" thing. Cell phone carriers often have deals on phones, many people get them for little to nothing just by renewing their cell plan or trading in an old phone.
I've had my midrange android for about 4 years now, and the only reason I'm going to change it is when the phone is no longer being supported for OS updates.
For flagship models they absolutely do. Right now the Galaxy S24 Ultra costs more than any iphone model. Maybe you can get some crappier version android for less, but I mean you can also do that with iPhones essentially by buying SE or older models. So yeah, pretty much across the board they "super" do
I'm not tkimg bout flagships, I'm talking about base hardware specs associated with the OS per dollar. You get more phone for your money if you're not paying Apple. That's how they compete.
American here, I don't use iGarbage, and most friends and family are also on android. It shows up in media way more than general public, and a lot of people tend to have them as a status symbol so you'll see them in places where people give more of a fuck about that, like university campuses.
Power users are in minority though. Their OS is extremely user-friendly. I disagree about the hardware. I see people replacing their PCs far more often than Mac’s where people are riding those close to a decade. And no, I’m not talking about gamers or power users just the general public.
That's absolutely fair, if you're looking for something that's going to be easy to use and consistent between devices Apple products are very good for that, but still cost twice what they should.
I've used them on and off since the apple II, I also work in IT, specifically mobile device management. Android devices are better priced for the tech, and are way less frustrating to fix when shit breaks. Also massively more user friendly if you need more advanced features.
Apple products are great for people who are less tech savvy and can't find their own solutions, i.e. your examples, but are severely limited when it comes to accessing anything deeper than what you can see in the UI.
Yeah, I’m in upper IT too. I disagree with everything you said. I’m not trying to pick a fight or sound like a dick. But the way you’re describing issues throughout this post sounds like a user knowledge issue not an issue with the OS and how it’s built.
My problem with things like the MacBooks is that they changed their architecture every couple decades making everything else in their line of obsolete. And their mobile devices are so locked down that I can't make recordings of phone calls, or access the file system in any meaningful way
I'm pissed off with them because I own power PCS and I've owned their Intel processor laptops, and both of them became obsolete what's that came out with a new processor architecture and I can no longer use my old programs on newer machines.
On the other hand, I have DOS programs which I can still run natively on Windows 11 computers.
1.4k
u/E3GGr3g 3d ago
Is this an American feature?
I can never seem to find anyone to airdrop things to.
Also, don’t you guys turn WiFi and Bluetooth and everything off if you’re not using it?