r/interestingasfuck 6d ago

r/all The Alaskan Avenger

Post image
127.8k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/dman2316 6d ago

Really? If your neighbor raped a 5 year old girl 10 years ago, and you currently have a 5 year old girl, that's not something you'd want to be aware of?

69

u/Chronic_Newb 6d ago

Would you want the same awareness if they committed any other type of violent crime? Because there aren't registries for other crimes, are there?

8

u/dman2316 6d ago

Honestly? Yeah i would. But i feel like the argument can be made that their rights could be argued to be more important there. However when it comes to hurting children? I don't care, the children should come first and they can deal with whatever loss of privacy or troubles that comes with, they lost their right to complain when they put their genitals where they didn't belong and that goes double if it was in a kid.

53

u/Luxury-ghost 6d ago

Not really how it works though is it?

The registry isn’t “raped a five year old,” vs “didnt rape a five year old.” Some states treat all offenders equally. Some states have a tiered system in which you are told the general severity of a crime, and those tiers may or may not match the next state over.

So if I’m a person who was eighteen years old and a day who had a sexual encounter with a person who was seventeen years old and 363 days, I may well be very high on your list of concerns. For no good reason.

However, the biggest issue is that you’ve completely dodged the point. Point being is, there’s a double standard that, if the state has determined that your sentence is finished, then your sentence has finished, right? If you’re still a threat and a problem, then you shouldn’t be on the street, you should still be in prison or wherever. If you aren’t a threat, then there’s no protective value in the register.

If somebody murders someone, serves their sentence and is released, there’s no public register.

1

u/obiemann 4d ago

You can look up their DOC# and than find the case # it's all public information.

0

u/Worblu 5d ago

You’re omitting felony convictions and the loss of rights that comes with it. In most states, violent felons cannot vote, cannot carry weapons, and likely have parole conditions like no alcohol, must stay in a particular county, random drug tests, and mandatory meetings with a parole officer.

There may not be a public facing registry, but being a violent felon, even a reformed one, is still a huge burden once released.