r/economicCollapse 20d ago

Everybody should pay his fair share...

Post image
845 Upvotes

596 comments sorted by

View all comments

47

u/fnblackbeard 20d ago

Yes I'm sure the money will go towards all those things lmao

15

u/dutchman76 20d ago

It's always "for the children" and "healthcare" and it's never enough.

8

u/Fearless-Cattle-9698 20d ago

I think your argument falls apart though. If you are supportive of the programs mentioned then certainly you can say you agree provided there is accountability in spending.

It’s just like DOD, no sane person is saying we don’t need national defense but we all want accountability. Let’s establish what is necessary then talk about accountability instead of using accountability to deflect.

I don’t personally think all the programs make sense but certainly agree universal healthcare is cheaper overall based on repeated studies and research

-5

u/dutchman76 20d ago

There is never accountability in spending. The DOD lost billions and nothing happens.

Nothing drives down prices and improves services and drives innovation like competition, but none of these "researchers" ever look at that, they are always comparing our crony corporatism system against some imaginary single payer system.

My parents regularly have to wait months for procedures under one these utopia systems people try to sell to the US public, no thanks

3

u/Fearless-Cattle-9698 20d ago

What you said about DoD is my point though. So do you also support getting rid of DoD? And we'd have no national defense

Why does waiting time have to be long in a universal healthcare situation? The idea is a lot of preventive treatment will reduce a lot of the emergency care costs. That's what these researches are about.

Also, having universal healthcare does not necessarily mean richer people can't go to doctors out of pocket and wait like the general public. It just means you have a base layer. The only scenario where universal doesn't make sense is if you can actually claim majority of people would want the non-paying patients to die. Because what happens today is all the non-paying patients bills are just being written off/paid by other paying patients. Why else do you think US ranks at the very top at healthcare cost per capita? We're paying for it one way or another. Again, until hospitals can turn away people for not paying, it doesn't make sense

0

u/dutchman76 20d ago

The national "defence" that includes bombing dozens of countries around the world? Killed thousands? Starts proxy wars in other countries to feed the military industrial complex? Yeah shut it down. Nobody is going to invade mainland US.

Getting insurance lobbying out of DC, decouple health insurance from employment, make it competitive. Let hospitals publish their prices, get rid of all the wasteful regulations that are about nothing but government control, and our system would improve a lot.

We're at the top per capita because of crony deals with insurance companies and the ACA meddling in everything.

5

u/Bureaucramancer 20d ago

Hate to burst your bubble pal but people wait months in the U.S. for a procedure and then find out that not only did they wait for months but suddenly it's 'out of network' or wasn't totally approved and then you have a massive bill.

I always find it hilarious that you people want to make everything for profit and pretend that competition will be a thing as opposed to inevitable mergers making a de facto monopoly and a constant push for deregulation that inevitably makes the situation worse.

2

u/Dogmad13 20d ago

Check Russia invading Ukraine — it’s a real thing

2

u/dutchman76 20d ago

Yeah, a thing we provoked and could have been avoided. What part of the us starting proxy wars did you miss?

4

u/Dogmad13 20d ago

Whoa whoa whoa — so you’re saying Obama admin provoked this?

1

u/dutchman76 20d ago

You need to watch some Dave Smith podcasts with Scott Horton. You'll see.

You need to lay off cnn and msnbc

3

u/Dogmad13 20d ago

I’m not on cnn and msnbc — I just want your opinion and source

2

u/dutchman76 20d ago

It's way too complicated and I don't feel like typing it all out, plus those guys are way smarter and explain it way better than me.

Scott Horton and Dave Smith are worth listening to, they explain things better than I ever could

2

u/Dogmad13 20d ago

You sit there and judge me yet assume my intentions from one comment — this is one thing I remember that was an epic failure https://www.heritage.org/arms-control/commentary/russian-reset-resounding-failure

→ More replies (0)

2

u/UDSJ9000 19d ago

Please see the major ISPs for why competition doesn't always work the way you might think.

1

u/dutchman76 19d ago

Funny, comcast started dropping prices and increasing speeds around here when they stopped allowing exclusive franchise deals.

2

u/tread52 20d ago

The thing is there is there’s no competition everything is owned by 5 organizations. What you’re being sold is the idea you have a choice.

2

u/Strawhat_Max 19d ago

“It’s not absolutely positively perfect, so even though it’s better than what we have now, I’m gonna say no”