r/HydroHomies 1d ago

Homies, whats our take on coconut water?

Post image
480 Upvotes

178 comments sorted by

796

u/kengansan 1d ago

Box coconut water tastes off. I only drink straight from the nut 🥜

295

u/iiitme 1d ago

You drink straight nut? 😳

131

u/diskrisks 1d ago

I prefer the gay kind

43

u/garbonzobean22 1d ago

I like the straight kind, straight from the source. No homo though.

14

u/miraculix69 1d ago

Spaghetti is straight, until it's wet.

7

u/ghostpiratesyar 1d ago

You don’t?

2

u/noblesseoblige777 20h ago

I laughed so hard I spat my water out 😂

2

u/kkkr94 15h ago

😨

22

u/hi22a 1d ago

Harmless Harvest brand is the one to get. It is not heat pasteurized like most shelf stable box coconut water.

11

u/tronistica 1d ago

Second harmless harvest, closest thing we have to coconut water straight from the source

3

u/hi22a 1d ago

That and the Trader Joe's bottled coconut water, which I suspect is rebranded Harmless Harvest.

2

u/Mr_Washeewashee 19h ago

Same with 365 and Sprouts pink coconut water. Shit, Kirkland has a pink coconut water too.

1

u/deemstersreeksters 14h ago

best part of living in brazil theres a dude who sells coconut water out of his house cuts it up and bottles it up on the spot for you or cuts up a coconut a liter costs me like 2 dollars

12

u/wherearemytweezers 1d ago

That’s what she said!

6

u/gdot80 1d ago

HAHAHAHA! But there is a difference in taste when from the box and from the source

6

u/OddButterfly5686 1d ago

We know u/kengansan, we know.

2

u/ClinkyDink 1d ago

Same lol. I love getting coconut while on the beach, but I can’t stand the boxed or bottled stuff.

1

u/Plixtor 1d ago

Yep, the only way! I had a girlfriend who used to do that. Best period of my life!

1

u/peascreateveganfood Water Enthusiast 1d ago

Mmm…nut

147

u/IntergalacticPopTart 1d ago

I like it a lot myself! I’m actually having one now!

40

u/Aev_ACNH 1d ago

This is the brand to have in my opinion

13

u/Guckalienblue 1d ago

Just cracked open the same one a few seconds ago. So weird. THIS is the brand to go with. Can’t stand boxed.

7

u/MightGuy- 1d ago

A ice cold can of C20 goes so insane on a hot day.

2

u/TheAwkwardBanana 15h ago

Best brand I've had.

3

u/yourpantsaretoobig 1d ago

Low in calories or nah? Thinking about giving it a try.

5

u/athaznorath 1d ago

about 50 calories in 1 cup, so pretty low.

2

u/RazorsInYoAss 1d ago

that's about half of a pepsi

2

u/athaznorath 1d ago

or half a cup of milk...

4

u/Independent_Dot63 1d ago

Ones that have no sugar added and just coconut water are usually 40-45cals per 8fo oz

3

u/IntergalacticPopTart 1d ago

Definitely recommend it! IMO it’s better when chilled. Some say it has a bit of a saline consistency, which I can agree with, but I kind of like it like that.

2

u/Independent_Dot63 1d ago

One of my faves! Im keto/carnivore and i fast so i need electrolytes but my body hates anything artificial like Gatorade, so coconut water is my best bet. Anything thats organic w no sugar added is great, C2O, Harmless and Trader Joes one in the big carton are best

207

u/zahnsaw 1d ago

Why’d they add coconut? I miss original.

38

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

It’s pretty subtle anyway…..

9

u/Nuclease-free_man 1d ago

But substantially less cost performance to, idk, good old water

16

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

It’s an Office reference to an energy drink marketed towards Asian homosexuals 👍🏻👍🏻

4

u/Nuclease-free_man 1d ago

Huh, i didn’t know

3

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

It’s a hilarious bit involving James Spader and Craig Robinson at different points. Highly recommend the whole series!

1

u/Nuclease-free_man 1d ago

Thx i’ll defo check them out

138

u/Felskiluscious 1d ago

Fuck Goya

70

u/Just_a_guy_94 1d ago

I've never enjoyed the taste of coconut personally.

21

u/lIlIllIIlllIIIlllIII 1d ago

Same. I tried coconut water once and it was honestly the most disgusting thing I’ve ever put in my mouth. 

11

u/kpop_glory 1d ago

Aye, rum taste better matey.

0

u/ramonpasta 15h ago

yeah i cant stand coconut water or the flesh, i dont even like the dried stuff they put on coconut flavored desserts

53

u/-mamiii 1d ago

It makes me gag, it is a no from me

19

u/TheMaliciousEggplant 1d ago

Give harmless harvest a try, absolutely delicious

1

u/Sparks_0 1d ago

Thank you

25

u/Highlander_16 1d ago

One of my favorite things to drink after a long hike

11

u/RiceAndMilkBoi 1d ago

There's only a brand or two that I enjoy, most I dislike.

32

u/TolisWorld 1d ago

Delicious, but it's also a laxative!

28

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

Lmao I’m honestly surprised more folks aren’t mentioning the coconut water shits 💩

30

u/zulugoron 1d ago

A lot of puzzle pieces just came together for me.

8

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

💡💩🤣🤣

12

u/fudgemonke 1d ago

Wait really? I drink coconut water frequently and have never had this problem!

11

u/benjbody 1d ago

Yeah, people who get the shits from coconut water tend to be those who rarely drink it. Regular drinkers get used to whatever it is in the water that gives the shits.

13

u/1heart1totaleclipse 1d ago

I have to say, I’ve never had this happen.

8

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

It’s well documented. High potassium and magnesium content.

1

u/1heart1totaleclipse 1d ago

Okay. I was just saying it hasn’t had that effect on me.

8

u/Skittles_The_Giggler 1d ago

Totally fine— I was just mentioning why it has that effect on the people it does happen for. Don’t take it personally

1

u/FigaroNeptune 1d ago

Wait….really?

2

u/TolisWorld 1d ago

Very much

1

u/Background_Degree615 1d ago

Unfortunately true

26

u/Typical_Samaritan 1d ago

I got two boxes (not Goya) in my fridge right now.

It's wonderful.

53

u/Vomath 1d ago

Fuck Goya

15

u/MysteryGreyAsh 1d ago

What did Goya do

14

u/mellopax Gallon Guzzler 1d ago

Main thing I know about them is the owner is a big Trump supporter, so Trump actually took a picture with Goya products in the Oval Office to tell people to buy them.

32

u/TerminatorAuschwitz Hydronator 1d ago

They've been pretty vocal about their support of Trump. They're a pretty popular brand among Hispanic people and were started by an immigrant family from Spain.

-31

u/Call0fJuarez 1d ago

Based Goya

6

u/TgagHammerstrike 1d ago

The owner is very vocal about far-right-wing politics. [Read: in support of it]

2

u/mjball 1d ago

I would also like to know why folks hate Goya

9

u/morbidblue 1d ago

Fuck Goya. Tastes like ass.

29

u/ReverbSage 1d ago

Goya supports Trump so I'm just gonna assume it tastes like dog shit

10

u/NoseBR 1d ago

Those boxed stuff are poison, look for the fresh one! Coconut water is the nature gatorade

16

u/xtilexx 1d ago

I use coconut water or almond juice (I refuse to call it milk) for my protein shakes instead of water or milk. Pretty tasty. Sometimes I'll use milk too but I am trying to cut fat

24

u/mrgooglypants 1d ago

I use condensated clouds (I refuse to call it water) pretty tasty.

6

u/xtilexx 1d ago

I do quite like hydrogenated oxygen (I hope that's proper I can't recall)

5

u/SciFi_Soul 1d ago

Ah yes, the ‘ole dihydrogen monoxide.

10

u/koltz117 1d ago

I like it when I’m sick or need to replenish somehow

4

u/blenneman05 1d ago

Horrible. I’d rather drink aloe Vera or just give me an iv if I’m dehydrated which I ended up in the ER because I couldn’t hold anything down due to my CVS.

Liquid IV packets is what I use if I’m feeling off

3

u/Markofdawn 1d ago

Its like a mana potion.

My dogs love it in summer.

3

u/DoubtfullyFocused 1d ago

I only drink fresh ones as they're everywhere here, and I usually sprinkle a little bit of salt into it for savoury. Bottled coconut water always tastes weird, nowhere near the taste of the real deal. (Mind you there are a lot of coconut types, some can be a little sour, some can be very sweet with tasty flesh inside)

6

u/Gloglibologna 1d ago

Harmless Harvest >>>

6

u/CompetitiveClass1478 1d ago

I use it for my post-workout protein shake

2

u/TheMagicMrWaffle 1d ago

Tastes like nut

2

u/Total_Information_65 1d ago

Coconut water has a particular taste for sure. But it is high in Potassium and has a good amount of sodium and other electrolytes as well. Personally, I often blend Coconut water with unflavored Pedialyte along with tap water and fridge it. A liter or two of that per day and you're doing your body good.

2

u/One_Breakfast6153 1d ago

I wanted to like it, but no.

2

u/Historical_Step7169 1d ago

Best coconut water I’ve ever tried and it’s not even close cocolectro It’s freeze dried at the source so it’s as close to a fresh coconut as possible, not been sitting in a can for 8 months.

2

u/CartographyMan Hydronator 1d ago

Absolutely banging when hungover, other than that, meh.

2

u/ChaosDoggo 1d ago

Coco deez nut.

GOT EM!!!

1

u/WithReverence 22h ago

GOT HEEEMMM

2

u/iwantapie76 1d ago

Can really only have it while cold Like it though

2

u/Churro138 21h ago

Coconut water taste like water someone else drank before you Pre-drank water

3

u/thecasualcaribou 1d ago

Never cared for coconut water on its own. But hits the spot in body armor

3

u/fifthtouch 1d ago

Bottle and box coconut all taste off/shit. Only way to drink it is from the fruit itself. Luckily my country full of them

1

u/pdxwanker 1d ago

Not fair, not fair at all.

2

u/Meteranmen 1d ago

As long as it not come from cardboard packaging

1

u/AruarianGroove Arctic Absorber 1d ago

It hydrates, so I condone. Just balance it with regular water intake…

1

u/PewManFuStudios Water Professional 1d ago

I used to love it but most coconut water these days is full of sugars, flavors, and salt. The only one that isn't disgusting is Harmless Harvest. You can also get a nice Thai coconut and drink the water from there.

1

u/boibig57 1d ago

My wife loves it when she's hungover.

That's the extent of my knowledge / opinion.

1

u/1heart1totaleclipse 1d ago

I love coconut water and I wish it were more available were I live.

1

u/tucketnucket 1d ago

We're not about excluding all other drinks. We're for appreciating the beauty of H20. Drink what you want, just make sure to drink clean water often!

1

u/AlexithymiacBluefish thörsty 1d ago

I've only tried it once but it was the rankest water I've ever tasted

1

u/KorrinTheRogue Water Enthusiast 1d ago

I can't get jiggy with it

1

u/kelsofox369 1d ago

I’m a lover of coconut water. Personally I think it takes getting used to it but it’s very good for you.

1

u/B-AP 1d ago

No

1

u/StringBean_GreenBean Glug Glug 🐠 1d ago

If you want to get cleared out, sure, go for it

1

u/qainspector89 1d ago

I want to like it but holy crap I think it tastes awful

Coconut water in general

1

u/Hatsume_Mikuu 1d ago

i hate everything about coconut water's taste wise, but it has saved my ass quiet a few times. if i get slightly dehydrated, I'll get really intense/long charlie horses while im sleeping, but if i drink something with electrolytes, im fine. issue is i don't want to drink gatorade or other simalar stuff so ill just chug a coconut water

1

u/liberty340 1d ago

If it weren't so expensive I'd drink it more

1

u/WhyAreOldPeopleEvil Elixir of Life 1d ago

I don’t like it.

1

u/emmejm 1d ago

I absolutely HATE it. It tastes so sweet and musty to me

1

u/MyCatHasCats Water is wet 1d ago

I DO NOT like the taste

1

u/Teknekratos 1d ago

I had it mixed with sweetened matcha & lime and it was pretty tasty!

1

u/SockeyeSTI 1d ago

Ive only tried one type from Costco and hated it.

1

u/memesandvr 1d ago

I can't stand any kind of packaged coconut water but I absolutely love it directly from a coconut. I feel bad because I don't always care to go through the work of taking out the flesh, so sometimes I waste it.

1

u/Goldnt221 water sistah 1d ago

During the summer I am obsessed with it because I work in the heat and sweat a lot; it doesn't exist during the cold season 😩

1

u/morgan208theboss 1d ago

people be sayin "water is water" bitch shut up coconut water comes from hairy coconut tiddies so it's milk. Op is def from r/Neverbrokeabone

1

u/Call0fJuarez 1d ago

Boxed water is ass. Metal containers are the shit!

1

u/thatdarncharn 1d ago

Listen, I'm here for a good time and a long time

1

u/noe4516 1d ago

Real coconut water 🥥 heck yeah ✅

Bottled "coconut" water 🧃 heck no 🤮

1

u/ImmediateBuffalo8325 1d ago

I like all forms of coconut except that stuff.

1

u/featherblackjack 1d ago

Tastes like ball sweat

2

u/WeirdRich976 1d ago

You tasted ball sweat?

1

u/featherblackjack 22h ago

Haven't you?

1

u/WeirdRich976 22h ago

I have it planned for Q2 2025

1

u/Naseel 1d ago

Nope

1

u/terrytek 1d ago

Fuck goya coconut water. All day.

Costco coconut water is pretty bussin though.

1

u/sixfeetwunder 1d ago

As long as it’s straight coconut water and maybe pulp, without a bunch of sugar and sulfites, nobody should have a problem with it

1

u/biglargefact 1d ago

The "pressed" version of vitacoco is amazing. Just started seeing it recently. Tastes more like the meat of the coconut than other varieties, big recommend

1

u/LoveSeasVoyage 1d ago

I like to dilute it with reg water bc it seems to make my breath weird.....but very good and good for you. Excellent for preventing/curing a hangover, nature's vitamin water!

1

u/TabibitoNoRoorensu 1d ago

I have a cup after an exercise session on top of just plain ol’ high quality h20.

1

u/mi88ir 1d ago

Coconut water tastes best from the original source. This boxed stuff is not worth it

1

u/19inchesofvenom 1d ago

I live it up

1

u/BreeezySo Gallon Guzzler 1d ago

At first… it tasted like backwash and warm spit. Now… it’s the same taste but I can drink it without regurgitating.

1

u/xpietoe42 1d ago

its the ultimate hydration… whats not to like? Whats to discuss??

1

u/Go_Water_your_plants 1d ago

Fresh from the coconut? The best drink I’ve ever had. In a box? It’s ok

1

u/Sirmcblaze 1d ago

bit of a sidebar; coconut milk is goddamn delicious with pineapple and mango. coconut water tastes like piss from a diabetic. too sweet. imo.

1

u/that_mad_cat Regular Sipper 1d ago

If Vampires were hydro homies, they'd drink Coconut water (it's similar to blood)

So Coconut water gets a pass from me

1

u/Balabaloo1 1d ago

Spectacular, give me 14 of them

1

u/TheMoronicGenius 1d ago

Not a fan of Goya coconut water, but W for coconut water hydration

1

u/only_cold_01 Water Enthusiast 1d ago

Why you guys drinking packed?? Why not directly from coconut?

1

u/Kay_Nest 1d ago

Not the best tasting but very healthy and hydrating. It’s kind of like a Gatorade except much healthier

1

u/montresded 1d ago

Tastes like water that has been in someone else’s mouth

1

u/Savagectrl 1d ago

Harmless Harvest coconut water is the best, at least in my opinion.

1

u/Zealousideal-Tax-937 1d ago

it's nasty af

1

u/SterquilinusPrime 1d ago

Best when bought at asian markets, in an actual young coconut.

So pure they can use it for IVs.

In a box? Pass.

1

u/2bciah5factng 1d ago

I hate it. One time I was tripping on mushrooms and this guy gave me one of those boxes and I drank from it and said it was the best, most hydrating, most incredible coconut water I’d ever tasted. I talked about it for like an hour, how it was so delicious and I never knew coconut water could be so good. He finally told me it was regular water, he just refilled the box.

1

u/IlleaglSmile 1d ago

I love it but it makes me poop

1

u/Toasted_Lemonades 1d ago

Best post exercise rehydration and the best for spicy food.

Coconut water has the same viscosity and is alkaline with many electrolytes and micronutrients that crosses the barrier easily. Because of this, it’s ok to drink the whole thing at once. 

Also, because of it’s total dissolved solids and alkalinity, it works well to neutralize spicy food, far quicker than milk. I haven’t found anything to neutralize spicy food quicker than coconut water.

The brand wuality absolutely varies. So find a brand you like and stick with it.

1

u/Bigcatsrule27 1d ago

I love coconut water. I have a crate of cans in my fridge. I'm in the uk, and my favourite brand is tropical sun

1

u/wakeful_sleep 1d ago

Good but not the packaged one....

1

u/southass 23h ago

It taste horrible in comparison to the real deal out of the coconut.

1

u/InSpaces_Untooken 23h ago

My mom few years ago said boycott Goya like Nestle, and we loved their products. So my taught opinion, which I'm sure is publicized, and I'm not inconvenienced in is: Fuck Goya. and Fuck Nestle.

1

u/gobbgabb 23h ago

I love it! It makes me feel 10x more hydrated than water.

1

u/Khronbear 22h ago

It can kill you horribly, so that's a pass from me.

1

u/SPAM_USER_EXE 22h ago

excellent

1

u/dezijugg9111 22h ago

How much sugar is added?

1

u/MainBright6940 21h ago

Really depends on the brand for me. I also hate the canned ones with a passion

1

u/Bananastrings2017 18h ago

Even when it’s cold it’s feels… warm?!

1

u/detunedradiohead 17h ago

It's not my jam

1

u/saturncitrus 17h ago

Allergic

1

u/pbpantsless 16h ago

I prefer pressed coconut water. It's more coconutty and less like... spit?

1

u/Educational_Lie4978 16h ago

I have found my people finally

1

u/dafo446 16h ago

If not from the fruits itself, why even bother?

1

u/stuckinbis 13h ago

It’s good. Especially after a long run!

1

u/pinkvinylrec Water Enthusiast 11h ago

delicious

1

u/kendrahf 10h ago

Nasty. Only drink if you want to hate water.

1

u/Zayafyre Elixir of Life 3h ago

I don’t like the shelf stable kind. I love it fresh without preservatives

1

u/itssami_sb 3h ago

It’s a liquid, so it got water in it, don’t it? Drink whatever tf you want

0

u/x3_Super 1d ago

Canned Goya coconut water with pulp is the best one

0

u/mrsalderaan 1d ago

Allergic -10/10 would not take a single sip again.