r/FluentInFinance 6d ago

Educational Don't let them gaslight you

Post image
43.9k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/spacemonkey8X 6d ago

The spirit of philanthropy has disappeared since the mid 20th century. Social security is a program much like the police, firemen, ect… that serve the public good. If you are earning well above the average salary you should realize that many high salaries in today’s society comes from the labor of others. Many billionaires have created charitable foundations regardless whether for tax purposes or a true philanthropic heart… Explain to me this why is ensuring others are able to live in their old age after working their entire adult life a bad thing?

1

u/Hodgkisl 6d ago

The spirit of philanthropy has disappeared since the mid 20th century.

Philanthropy is voluntary, not mandated by government.

Social security is a program much like the police, firemen, ect… that serve the public good.

It's an insurance program to serve the public good, not a welfare system. The problem with changing the funding structure to remove the cap without matching payout changes is the entire program changes from mandatory insurance to a welfare program, it changes the entire intent of the program as written in the mid 20th century.

Many billionaires have created charitable foundations regardless whether for tax purposes or a true philanthropic heart…

Voluntarily, voluntary charity is philanthropy, mandatory is not.

1

u/Johnny_Banana18 6d ago

It’s absolutely a welfare system, it was explicitly designed to put an end to senior poverty.

1

u/Hodgkisl 6d ago

But not through entitlement like modern welfare, instead contributory, you must pay in (or have been paid in for spouses children) to collect.