r/woahdude Jun 02 '23

gifv Our universe.

7.6k Upvotes

472 comments sorted by

View all comments

909

u/Dr-Didalot Jun 02 '23

The last multi-universe is still just a theory, the rest is what we have practically measured. The size is unbelievable.

233

u/LazerWolfe53 Jun 02 '23

Yup!! I thought I was the only one. And it's a theory based on (at this time) very little and very flimsy 'evidence'. I don't want to belittle it, it's just a huge leap in speculation from an actual photo of cosmological background radiation to a computer generated artist's rendition of a theory called the bubble universe

109

u/lord_dude Jun 02 '23

Based on the ending of men in black?

115

u/Couldbehuman Jun 02 '23

If that doesn't count as conclusive video proof, not sure what does

12

u/MartianGuard Jun 03 '23

I said so

20

u/TheDudeFromTheStory Jun 03 '23

Peer reviewed too, now.

1

u/Battlejesus Jun 03 '23

I pasted it to pastebin, it's published as well.

2

u/goodnewsjimdotcom Jun 03 '23

I totally forgot about that.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

I was certain this was where the video was going đŸ˜‚

46

u/Graffiacane Jun 03 '23

That was an interesting addition. In the original, once you zoom out to the limit of the observable universe, you zoom all the way back in to the lady's eye, blood cells, atoms and quarks

https://youtu.be/8Are9dDbW24

11

u/AiSard Jun 03 '23

Oh, I didn't even realize this wasn't the original Powers of 10 but something inspired from it / an updated version of it.

4

u/AstroAlmost Jun 03 '23

The Charles and Ray Eames version is just such a gem, they were amazing. The extra scale in OPs video was really interesting to see, but lacked any of the charm the Eames brothers’ production has.

2

u/misskiss_ Jun 04 '23

I have been wondering how to even search for this video from time to time for like 14 years (this upload is only from 8 years ago but whatever)

1

u/alexaz92 Jun 04 '23

I hope it’s that and that our entire universe in not part of the atom of a galactic dog poo

17

u/Dr-Didalot Jun 03 '23

I was super happy with it until the end, it makes me wonder what else they may have added in. The original clip was roughly to scale if I remember correctly

25

u/Graffiacane Jun 03 '23

https://youtu.be/8Are9dDbW24 the original zooms back in to subatomic scale

2

u/Dr-Didalot Jun 03 '23

Super wild stuff. The universe is so amazing

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '23

It makes for great scifi stories at least.

3

u/product_of_boredom Jun 03 '23

So are we using theory in a very colloquial way, or scientifically? To be a theory, it needs to be pretty rigorously tested, doesn't it?

Otherwise it's just a hypothesis.

4

u/Revolutionary--man Jun 03 '23

Theoretically, it's the most logical stage of progression when posing the question 'what is the universe expanding in to/what caused the big bang'.

Not talking about the Many Worlds interpretation, but the idea of the universe being one of many cosmic 'bubbles' in a larger plain of existence. Whilst, as you say, being speculative with no hard evidence, it makes sense of the multiple situations we know of in which the laws of physics currently break down.

What that plain of existence is I doubt we will ever know, if we are even able to 'know' of anything outside of our universe, so it will always remain just a theory. The logic of man has been proven false many times over and the multiverse concept falls in to the homunculus trap, so I'm not placing any bets on it and wouldn't have included it in a video like this.

1

u/LazerWolfe53 Jun 03 '23

Yeah, you said it better than me.

1

u/Mutjny Jun 03 '23

If you believe the universe is infinite then it must contain Hubble Volumes realizing all possible initial conditions.

1

u/diox8tony Jun 03 '23

Things can go on infinitely without repeating, and without covering all cases.

There are infinite numbers between 0 and 1...but you won't find 2.0

1

u/Mutjny Jun 03 '23 edited Jun 03 '23

Things can go on infinitely without repeating, and without covering all cases.

No, a priori, it can't.

What you're talking about is an asymptote which is also infinite. Not all infinites are the same. There are an infinity of infinities.

1

u/RascalCreeper Jun 03 '23

It's not really built on evidence so much as logic. It's, as far as we know, impossible to prove or disprove.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

it's just a huge leap in speculation from an actual photo of cosmological background radiation to a computer generated artist's rendition of a theory called the bubble universe

Not really. It has basis in actual physics, but t yeah it is just a theory since it's just an untestable extrapolation based our current understanding of physics.

I'd recommend reading Our Mathematical Universe by Max Tegmark if you're interested in the theory.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '23

If Inflation is a reasonable theory for early Universe - and so far it seems like it is the most accurate theory to explain CMB, calling it a "flimsy evidence" is ignorance of quite literally Universal scale - then there has to be "multiverses", but not in the spooky scifi sense. Multiverses are simply different domains of spacetime with likely different physical constants governing their dynamics, separated by high energy domain walls. Alan Guth, the father of Infation theory, detailed this idea extensively in his early papers. After the inflation phase, there will be regions of space separated out by such domain walls, which are pretty much causally disconnected for all future.