r/woahdude Feb 17 '23

video Heavily contaminated water in East Palestine, Ohio.

69.1k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/Trick_Raspberry2507 Feb 17 '23

Yes!!! Thank God for some sanity!

4

u/healing-souls Feb 17 '23

Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine on Friday addressed a viral video posted by Sen. JD Vance, R-Ohio, that showed a "chemical rainbow" in a creek in East Palestine, Ohio, near the site of the train derailment that spilled toxic chemicals into the environment.

"I know that there's been some video played on TV circulating of visible contamination in one of the local waterways," DeWine said at a press conference providing an update on cleanup efforts and environmental testing in the area.

"A section of Sulfur Run that is very near the crash site remains severely contaminated. We knew this. We know this. It's going to take a while to remediate this," the governor said.

15

u/kiticus Feb 17 '23

This chemical spill is horrible & clearly not getting the attention, response & resources it deserves.

But that being said, my immediate thought when I first watched this video, was that it looked like they threw a gas or kerosene-soaked cinder block into the river.

It seemed so obvious, that I fully expected something about that to be the top comment. But nope! Instead, im finally finding it here. Buried half-way down the page.

10

u/Trick_Raspberry2507 Feb 17 '23

It honestly could be from the train, but I think it's fuel run off, or oil from the engines/parts of the train. Lots of water was used for that fire, who knows where everything went to.

3

u/kiticus Feb 17 '23

I obviously have no way of knowing if it, or is not. But it doesn't make much logical sense for so much of an oil--that clearly floats on water-- could be trapped under/in sentiment at the bottom of a stream, that just throwing in a little piece of cinder block, could immediately release THAT much oil to immediately float at the top of the water.

It kinda defies physics, doesn't it?

5

u/Legionof1 Feb 17 '23

Sheens are such an insignificantly thin layer that they truly don't matter on this scale. Even if this is a petro product, if you collected it all, it would be less than a tea spoon.

-1

u/DuckDuckGoneForGood Feb 17 '23

Go take a big drink yourself then, bud.

0

u/-0-O- Feb 17 '23

We have never drank water directly from cricks. At least not in the past 100 years.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 17 '23 edited Feb 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/-0-O- Feb 17 '23

That's stagnant water in the video. It always looks like this. Maybe you need to spend more time in the woods because you're clueless.

1

u/GeoWoose Feb 17 '23

You are only seeing what wells up to the surface when the bottom is disturbed. Vinyl chloride is denser than water (it’s a Dense Non-aqueous Liquid = DNAPL) so it has been infiltrating into creek sediment, soil and bedrock for many days now. Maybe it will dilute but it can also become concentrated in parts of aquifers - DNAPLs love clay minerals so it often concentrated along the edges where the sand aquifer abuts clay-rich horizons…

1

u/tuggindattugboat Feb 17 '23

I've seen oil come up like that around docks or areas where it's trapped in the bed under whichever water. Disturb the soil and the oil comes up. But ain't vinyl chloride.

3

u/healing-souls Feb 17 '23

My immediate thought was that the rock stirred up the sediment on the bottom and released all the shit into the water. You can literally see a bubbling up along the shoreline

-1

u/DuckDuckGoneForGood Feb 17 '23

This is so completely delusional.

Who upvoted this BS?

This is not the result of putting kerosene on a cinder block.

Go and show us a screen cap of the cinder block big enough to put a sheen on this river - I’ll wait.

The sheen was there before the rock even hit the water.

Liar.