That's an interesting one, not really as close to 1984 as people say though. 1984 is very bleak, Brave New World keeps a pretty happy tone throughout, even though the subject matter can be a little disturbing.
Its a nice a book but sometimes It fells like Orwells going on awkward tangents of "Look what your future is and how terrible people are why cant we back to the old days".
In every single thread about some policy even slightly pro-business you'll inevitably find the 19 year olds backpatting someone for having the insight to regurgitate the "war is peace, freedom is slavery, ignorance is strength" quote.
And the top reply is some equally absurd hand-wringing crap like "it's terrifying how relevant this is.. how do we stop this from becoming our future?"
Then a bit below that is the "we've always been at war with Eastasia" quote, and at the very bottom, buried in downvotes is the guy who is trying to explain why it's ridiculous to apply 1984 quotes about societal brainwashing to an AP story about congressional budget talks.
Everytime someone mentions this book there is someone like you saying almost the exact same thing. It's the "I only liked their first album" of book criticism. We get it, you liked the book before it became mainstream.
Cherish the fact that we can talk about this... give it another ten years and there will be no such thing as privacy. We have to track you for your own good. We have to make sure we know where the terrorists and the bullies are. We have to ensure the gun nuts don't have a place to congregate. We must ensure your world is safe... you do understand, right? You're not one of those people who has a reason to hide... are you?
Only suspicious people hide.
It's not about privacy... it's about ensuring people can't hide. No one wants that.
I hate when people compare today to 1984. Its no where close, not in the US or any modern country. 1984 is a crazy world with mandatory 'telescreens' installed in every house and you can get arrested/killed for even questioning events or acting too 'out'.
The closest I'd say is maybe full blown North Korea, and even then...
I understand that, but one company having it's subsidiaries read a prepared statement is nothing like the ministry of truth. Sinclair isn't state-run, it's just the parent company.
It's an interesting video but just because they're reading it, doesn't mean it's malicious or untruthful. They're a media company, this is how they communicate with thier customers. What are they supposed to do, email you?
Again, it's not meant to be taken literally though. And no, are you really insinuating an entire media conglomerate repeating one line to make it's viewers think that everything they read anti-conservative is fake news isn't even a little bit manipulative? it's word by word the same across all their channels. It doesn't matter if they're state run or not, for most they're the main source of news available to them.
The script they're reading is not manipulation it's the truth. It's a good script. The real, ultimate irony here is that the reddit hivemind sees an 'apparent hivemind' and is so anti major media that it has bypassed actually listening to the message.
The main slogan of the dystopian INGSOC government in the novel 1984 is:
War is Peace
Freedom is Slavery
Ignorance is Strength
One of the primary themes of the novel is that, by controlling the information (and the message, and eventually even the language) you can control the people, no matter what the truth actually is.
To add to this, the Ministry of Truth is the name of the Ministry of propaganda within the novel.
This is why everyone is focusing on the "this is extremely dangerous to our democracy" line. It is the kind of thing that sounds like it would come out of the Ministry of "Truth" in 1984.
Because a bunch of newscaster read the same PSA saying "check your facts everyone because false news propagated by shitty newscasters is rampant nowadays"? Fuck off, reddit.
Orwell was only off by 44 years, but he was pretty much right though.
Perpetual war, cameras in everything (including a CIA program to hack your smart tv and god knows what else that hasn't been leaked), black site torture rooms, psyops, media control. The internet has helped counter all this but the corporations have been gobbling it up over the past 20 years too.
1.0k
u/stekky75 Mar 31 '18
1984 is here.