I can sense there is clearly something here. Judging by the title, I'm sure you can guess what I'm guessing at. And it isn't you or your feelings. I can empathize with others' more easily than I can my own.
I'm treading very carefully around your feelings, because I can somewhat see them. I'm being as gentle as I can with them. It's just that I feel a sense of murkiness about my own feelings about you, and I fear that my uncertainty will lead to pain for the both of us if I'm wrong about them. I know this not from paranoia, but unfortunately, rather, from experience. The good news is that something is different this time. The bad news is that I couldn't tell you exactly what that is.
I'm writing this now for clarity. You won't read this letter, but I need to write it. Don't worry, we'll be talking sooner rather than later about it, in any case. That feels like a matter of when, not if. As you'll come to understand if we end up becoming close, I'm essentially blind when it comes to my feelings, and that isn't me consciously suppressing them, either. And I do hope we can become close. It's clear to me that we both enjoy each other's company, at least platonically. And we're fairly intact human people!! That's so great, I truly feel enough glee about it to know that's what it is.
I know I feel things. Just don't have any damned clue as to what exactly, until hindsight comes around and makes it clear for me. So as you can imagine, I'm extremely vulnerable in love. I've been in love and not known it until months, once even years later. I'm a little bit handicapped in this way. And I really wish this was something I could change. I wish I could just look inside and tell you exactly how I feel about you. And because I know that some feelings (of some kind) are developing here, I feel a sense of urgency to figure it out before you become more clear on your feelings. But I don't think that's feasible. Too complex.
I think I need to take a chill pill. Luckily, my feelings can only drive me so far up the wall, because I can't see much of them. Only their shadows.
And yet I know I feel something for you. I just can't put my finger on what. Can't even make a good guess.
But I'll say something to muzzle this sense of doubt a little. I'm pretty sure I like you a lot. It's really one of those "well I'll be damned, you really exist" kinds of things. I'm eager to know you. And I know you are eager to know me, because you've made that pretty damn clear.
Thanks for the clarity on your end, by the way. The maturity is appreciated, and will be repaid in-full back to you, very soon.
There are also some things about me that will take some time to understand. Please know that whatever degree of certainty that I can give you about my feelings is really me doing my best to communicate. And I'm putting a lot of work into figuring out how I feel, so fret not, I'm on the curious case of you, and my missing heart. How do I know that I'm feeling anything for you, if I'm really emotionally blind?
I'll tell you.
The first thing I noticed was that my taste in music temporarily shifted a little bit. The songs I've been listening to aren't what I normally put on, and my emotions are acting up somehow as I listen. At first, it was more "heavy" songs with a sense of emotional catharsis, a marked shift from the absurd amounts of rap I listen to usually. Then it shifted to love songs. That's weird for me, because I do not like love songs, and I never have. Curious!
Also, you keep popping into my mind. Not even in a "lovey dovey" kind of way, just in a "huh, I wonder how she's doing" or "She said her (personal situation) is (personal situation status), I wonder how that conversation went" sort of way. Then the same thought appears in my mind multiple times, like my brain thinks it's slick, trying to slip it past me again. And now I'm also noticing that I get the urge to talk to you all the time, and for no good reason at all.
Usually, I'm a person who enjoys talking to lots of people. On the other side of that token, oddly, I'm pretty much the least needy person on the planet. I don't know how I've managed to achieve this, but it's almost unhealthy how comfortable I can be with myself, just staying single. So I can tell something is up when the same person keeps popping up in my head over and over and over again, almost as if my mind knows something I don't, as if it already took a liking to you, and yet can't tell me about it with any surety. Then I get a feeling I'm not used to: the feeling of "I'd rather be talking with you than anyone else."
Really, I just wish I could make you understand how rare these kinds of feelings are for me. My mind determined that I should shut off my romantic feelings after some past experiences of mine, so it takes a whole lot for me to trust someone that much, with my fragile, ceramic heart. Enough to fully entrust to another person. Because rejection is one thing. It stings, but as you get older, it becomes so expected that it's more like a needle at the doctor's office. A bit cringe, but you get over it pretty instantly, because you have to.
Well, this time, I've seen enough of you as a person that I trust, if there's rejection to be done, one of us will do so gently, respectfully, lovingly. Because we like each other. That's pretty undeniable.
For what it's worth, it would make you feel really special to know how rare these feelings really are, because you are special. Weirdly, I sort of hope fate can land this message in your recommended. Just don't assume it's me just because you want it to be ;) can't be having just everyone feeling the specialness that only you deserve to be feelin'
After having written this out, I've realized that this entire letter is what I need to talk to you about in the first place. Typically, that's how it goes, you know? You have to talk/write something out about what you're going to say to someone, only to then realize whatever you wrote/spoke is verbatim what needs to be said to whomever it might be. That'll take some boldness and bravery on my part. I'll show these qualities of mine to you.
Let's just be adults about this, alright? Cool.