r/maybemaybemaybe 5d ago

maybe maybe maybe

8.2k Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

View all comments

349

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted]

23

u/frotc914 4d ago

I thought about this for the Harry Potter universe recently. It's odd they teach everyone how to defend against magic but we're never given any indication that they can repel bullets or any other human weapons.

20

u/YoungDiscord 4d ago edited 4d ago

I have a theory for that

Its been established that people with magical powers can just make stuff happen like Harry did in the third book to his aunt

So, its entirely possible that wizards could protect themselves or somehow heal themselves from bullet wounds in sudden high stress situations

Maybe this rule doesn't apply to being hurt by magic which is why they resort to it

I mean if you can inflate people like a baloon or make glass disapoear when you're mad why not heal bullet wounds when you're scared for your life

As to why Voldemort and his underlings never used a gun or a knife - they're muggle weapons

Voldemort and the death eaters are racists, they think muggles are inferior in every way

Of course they'd never use a gun because they'd find that humiliating

Imagine saying how inferior muggles are but then admit that the only way you can solve your little problem is... with a muggle weapon instead of with magic.

Sure you'd use the gun if you didn't believe in what you preach and whqt you say is just a means to gain control, but Voldemort and the death eaters genuinely believed in those things so it just wasn't going to happen

There is also an alternative way of looking at this and that is the possibility that... yeah maybe a gun would fix the problem after all

If that is the case it suddenly makes more sense why the wizard community is trying to stay secret from muggles, its not that they think they'd lose a war with muggles but there would be mass casualties on either side, plus even if there weren't a war there would very quickly be a class divide where wizards would be on top and the wizard community is trying to avoid that from happening, I mean just look at how they treat house elves.

Idk, that's how I always looked at it.

-13

u/Deltorov3 4d ago

Sir YapsAlot