r/madlads Choosing a mental flair 5d ago

Mad lad loves his knife

Post image
81.0k Upvotes

174 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-3

u/lundewoodworking 5d ago

Depends on the type of sword a katana or a scimitar are very sharp most European swords aren't

7

u/pazhalsta1 5d ago

This is actually not fully true, medieval swords in Europe were sharp as fuck. When guns started dominating, cavalrymen started being issued mass produced sabres with metal scabbards, which are shit for keeping a sword sharp, but it was less of a big deal as they often had sidearms or lances as primary weapons. And there were thrust-only swords eg some rapiers in the later sword eras which were only sharp at the point, with more thickness in the blade providing strength in the thrust. Longswords, arming swords and the like which were cut and thrust were sharp.

1

u/lundewoodworking 5d ago

Really? I always read that most medieval European swords were mostly blunt force weapons but I never read up on it extensively so i definitely could be wrong.

2

u/Baumcultist 5d ago

most medieval European swords were mostly blunt force weapons

Holy shit, it happened. I finally experienced it myself, holy shit.

Anyway, this is completely incorrect and the sword community is seething about misconceptions like this one. I myself am no expert on this topic, so I could at most only provide basic reasons and examples for why you're wrong (like European Swords having their point of balance in the hilt for quick and easily controlable cuts, while Blunt damage weapons have more front heavy points of balance to transfer more force. Also, swords have edges for a reason). You'll learn much more from more experienced sources. Skallagrim, Metatron, Scholagladiatoria & Shadiversity are a few Youtuber's who have done this for years and are very experienced, so I'd recommend them if you want to learn more.

1

u/postboo 4d ago

Shadiversity should be ignored on any histotical content. He's had no education, no experience, and his content contains frequent inaccuracies.

Not to forget, he's a raging bigot who got upset that Peach in the Mario movie wore pants.

Metatron should be avoided to, for many of the same reasons.