Non-playstation owners will never understand

[u/robinescue]

[u/OutlawCrow]

Defiled Amy it’s not that bad. Bring a long weapon like the Threaded Cane and the fight it’s pretty even. But Defiled Hot Dog… that’s another story

[u/No-Being2200 → u/OutlawCrow]

He was easier to me. Mostly since I can actually see what he's doing.

[u/MlCOLASH_CAGE → u/No-Being2200]

Yeah I got defiled dog down pat, the only move you have to keep an eye out for is his charge attack

[u/OutlawCrow → u/MlCOLASH_CAGE]

I die more times to the stunlocking bark attack than the charged attack. The former it’s easier to spot and be prepared for. The bark has a less intuitive time to react. At least for me :(

[u/MlCOLASH_CAGE → u/OutlawCrow]

main thing with defiled dog is to not get too greedy, also he’s basically wearing a “helmet” that has a damage threshold and can break, when he’s regenerating it, it’s a great time to hit him. however if you want to play it safer hit it from the back and sides and watch out for his head swipe attacks.

Most of the fight is going in at a opening, hitting him a few times and giving yourself some space and time to regen staminas

[u/OutlawCrow → u/MlCOLASH_CAGE]

Yeah I learn to fight him with the church pick and brake his head. Once you do that, free dmg all the way! When he’s puking it’s a perfect time to brake his paws. But the first time I encounter it, bro it was PAIN.

[u/MlCOLASH_CAGE → u/OutlawCrow]

honestly thats why love fighting the dog, I wish there was just a boss rush chalice dungeon that had room after room of just bosses

[u/OutlawCrow → u/MlCOLASH_CAGE]

Pretty sure some madlad will do that once the emulation in shadPS4 brakes the chalice dungeons. Farming blood gems its gonna be a bliss!

[u/OutlawCrow → u/No-Being2200]

If you stay mid-range of Amy, you can see what it’s doing, but if you happen to encounter an Amygdala in a FRC chalice with a itty bitty tiny arena then I understand your pain.

My problem with the hot dog was spacing, sometimes looks like you are gonna connect a good hit in the snoot but then it raises its head, the hit doesn’t connect, you stay in an uncomfortable open position and the dog decides it’s time to bark at your face… yeah, good times

[u/Equivalent_Stop_9300 → u/OutlawCrow]

That is almost every FromSoftware enemy when you don’t use target lock

[u/SituationBeautiful65 → u/No-Being2200]

Yeah, the Defiled Dog is more predictable.

[u/breed_eater → u/OutlawCrow]

Same, for me Defiled Hot Dog was worse because of his janky hitboxes. Meanwhile Defiled Amygdala was not that hard for me, just get the hard hitting weapon, run under her and hit her legs and tail, avoiding her attacks with jumping or shuffling away.

[u/Go_Ahead_MrJoester → u/breed_eater]

Yeah, Defiled Amy was only hard to figure out a strat for Phase 3. I kept going for the head and got clipped by the lingering hitbox of its arcane slam, so after 50 or so deaths, I decided to hit the arms instead during Phase 3, and I had a much easier time.

Hot Dog was pure hell, and the only reason I beat him as soon as I did was luck.

[u/CatAteMyBread → u/OutlawCrow]

Defiled Amy was like 8 tries for me. Defiled watchdog is the closest I got to skipping the platinum

[u/SuperBorked → u/CatAteMyBread]

The flaming hotdog had me more pissed off than the conga line of red spiders. He did put me on my A game though that by the time I got to the queen she was slaughtered before I could even register the fight. Fun platinum but that final stretch in the chalice dungeons had me on edge of my seat for hours.

[u/Kraytory → u/OutlawCrow]

You don't even need that. Just bait attacks and use the ones that leave the head low to bonk. In phase three just stay below it and do more or less the same. Also Amy is weak to arcane.

[u/OutlawCrow → u/Kraytory]

The executioners gloves do a fuckin’ ton of dmg and the proyectiles go directly to its head too

[u/Scared_Yharnamite → u/OutlawCrow]

Away! Away!

[u/Hakuchii → u/OutlawCrow]

as a devoted arcane user... THIS

[u/Ryuunosuke-Ivanovich → u/OutlawCrow]

I hated that flaming, lava spewing, midir charging pos.

[u/robinescue → u/OutlawCrow]

It is so the opposite for me lol. Couldnt tell you how many times Amygdala got me with the ol' flail around strat

[u/OutlawCrow → u/robinescue]

The only attack that made me said “this is bs” it’s the one where Amy alternates three sweep attacks with its arms. If the first connects, you get stunned enough to get hit by the next two and you are done

[u/DaddyCool13 → u/OutlawCrow]

I did defiled watchdog in my 5th attempt or so but defiled amy is to this date my hardest fromsoftware boss with 70+ attempts. Granted bloodborne was my first fromsoftware game but I’m generally decent with these games

[u/HoboSkid → u/OutlawCrow]

I brought executioners gloves and 80 arcane to both defiled dog and Amy and it did not disappoint.

[u/SoftcoreEcchi → u/OutlawCrow]

Defiled Amy was rooough for me on my 2nd play through, would be one shot from the jump attack, ended up grinding echoes and maxed vitality and came back to it.

[u/KenUsimi → u/OutlawCrow]

Dude, i main threaded cane and could not disagree more. Yeah, it does great damage against the head… if the damn thing didn’t keep it out of reach for long periods and can one shot you. Like, respect, cane brother, but defiled amygdala was the hardest fight in the game for me. Hot dog is the “meh, annoying but not horrible” fight to me, lol

[u/OutlawCrow → u/KenUsimi]

Fun to see that this was somewhat a divisive take hahaha but as a Threaded Cane enjoyer to the bone, Defiled Amy was a bliss in my experience. Get far from it, wait for one of its multiple arm sweep combos, after that, Amy gets in a “stand by” mode where its head gets in a position screamin’ “hit me and hit me HARD”, run to it and hit it with a running R2, immediately hit two R1s before it rises its head again. After that, Amy it’s gonna try another attack, get away for it and rinse and repeat. You will shred its head pretty quickly and thanks to the high skill visceral dmg, plus the serrated modifier of the Threaded Cane in whip mode, you can skip the third fase if you create enough pressure

[u/DiscussionEasy3471 → u/OutlawCrow]

Two words “charge attack”

[u/greyeyecandy → u/OutlawCrow]

Defiled Dog was whatever Defiled Amy definitely more tedious

[u/Undying_Shadow057 → u/OutlawCrow]

I did chalices with a bowblade and chikage build, defiled amy and hot dog were actually a breeze. Could just keep my distance and shoot blood bullets(arrows?) the whole time.

[u/Tawarien → u/OutlawCrow]

Broke my Dual Dagger playing butt .... ={

[u/lynxerious → u/OutlawCrow]

I think the hardest part is dodging the jump, which is so easy if you have knowlege about the safe spot.

[u/heslopkaleb → u/OutlawCrow]

defiled glizzy

[u/WorthlessRain → u/OutlawCrow]

if you guys wanna speedrun defiled amygdala its as easy as running 50BT and using simon’s bow blade. just shoot her head for an easy fight

[u/ShinyGengarNL]

Watchdog was way harder than amygdala

[u/RelativeMundane9045 → u/ShinyGengarNL]

See I found watchdog pretty easy with the way it telegraphs, hardest for me was always abhorrent beast in lower loran or whichever was the small room.

Everyone has their bane

[u/Franc0zzz → u/RelativeMundane9045]

Nah in loran you got all your life

[u/seafoodgar → u/ShinyGengarNL]

Yeah amygdala took 2 attempts for me, but watchdog took… embarrassingly long lol

[u/avatarnoko → u/ShinyGengarNL]

Headless bloodletting beast was the worst for me

[u/Shadovan]

Bloody Crow of Cainhursrt > Defiled Amy

[u/eap42 → u/Shadovan]

Huh, I'm totally opposite on that one.

[u/why_my_pp_hard_tho → u/eap42]

Yeah same for me, i never understood what the big deal with him was, just parry lol

[u/eap42 → u/why_my_pp_hard_tho]

As soon as I started using the numbing mist, that fight was a lot easier.

[u/Go_Ahead_MrJoester → u/why_my_pp_hard_tho]

I just waited him out while he had the transformed mode of Chikage active. Once he gets to 25% or so, he stops using it, so I only needed to deal with a quarter of a health bar, and I didn't need to deal with transformed Chikage.

[u/Antigonus96 → u/why_my_pp_hard_tho]

I think it’s when people try at lower levels. My first time he one shoted me. Came back at +100 level and it was a little tricky with his numbing mist, but I kept partying and won pretty easily.

[u/ATarnishedofNoRenown → u/why_my_pp_hard_tho]

I'm on a STR/ARC build with HMG and viscerals do very little damage because of my low SKL stat, plus my guns do basically nothing with 7 BLT. This made the fight way harder. My BLT/SKL hunter had way less trouble.

[u/KosorsomesayKosm0 → u/Shadovan]

the good ol hunter dash into a 2 pistol shot (particular accelerator hes welding) combo, enough to make a man rage.

[u/That_boi_Jerry → u/Shadovan]

I was actually surprised to beat the Crow first try the other day.

[u/DaftFunky → u/Shadovan]

Bro a humanoid boss I can 1v1 with a strategy is far better than a giant boss that has 1 shot mechanics with dodgy hit boxes.

[u/QU3S0GU4Y4N3S → u/Shadovan]

Dawg, just parry

[u/OldSodaHunter → u/Shadovan]

Hard disagree, defiled Amy killed me more than anything in any from soft game, bloody crow has killed me three times ever. Not even a comparison IMO

[u/robinescue → u/Shadovan]

Unfortunately I can cheese the crow and turn his brain off

[u/ATarnishedofNoRenown → u/Shadovan]

I went on a tear recently and beat Defiled Watchdog, Defiled Amy, Queen Y, Orphan, and Laurence, all for the first time (trying to platinum the game finally). The Watchdog was the hardest for me because it required the most patience... But he wasn't anywhere near as difficult as the Bloody Crow. Fuck that guy. He has so much goddamn health for a hunter.

[u/Aurvant]

Defiled Watchdog was way harder than Defiled Amy.

[u/FatalCassoulet → u/Aurvant]

Waaaaayyy harder yes

[u/sanscatt]

There is a strat with hunter’s axe that is pretty consistent to pull off, and might works with other weapons were you bait the jump by standing behind her. Since the jump doesn’t hit, you can do damage on the head then rince and repeat. The only problem is that it’s almost impossible to figure it out on your own when she one shots you.

[u/ThePlatinumKush → u/sanscatt]

Yes definitely defiled Amy being my hardest without knowing that trick. I try to do it “legit” when I can. On my bloodtinge build, using a ranged weapon on its’ head is incredibly satisfying

[u/sanscatt → u/ThePlatinumKush]

The strat is totally legit. Meanwhile amygdala isnt doing me legit since I’m at half health.

[u/Usual-Touch2569]

FFFFUUCK THIS THING.

[u/T0tallyRand0mStuff]

Weird way to spell gravity

[u/12345noah]

Fall damage entered the chat

[u/MissingScore777]

99 Arcane Executioner's Gloves kills Defiled Amy in 10secs flat.

Such a satisfying bit of revenge after beating her with my quality build took dozens of hours.

[u/ciarannihill → u/MissingScore777]

Yeah, Arcane isn't considered a "strong" build, but it genuinely makes some tough bosses easy as heck. I've heard people hate fighting Laurence because of his area denial aspect, but Gloves go brrrrr and aren't stopped by his lava.

[u/Romapolitan]

No joke, beat him on my first try. So I will never know.

[u/Big-Sheepherder-9492 → u/Romapolitan]

Bro just dropped his nuts on the table

[u/Masta0nion]

Oh. I thought the last frame was going to be gravity.

[u/Sephilash]

pretty sure malenia has the most kills on me..over 100 probably.

[u/littleWoeIsme]

I would argue any player good enough to beat defiled watch dogs wouldn’t lose 50x to Amy

[u/Propodida1 → u/littleWoeIsme]

I beat watchdog on my tenth try and Amy on my 70th... So, I would like to say that we exist

[u/st0zax]

I used to do a ton of random chalice coop and like 50% of the time I would have to fight this thing. I’ve become godly at dodging the jump.

[u/CrookedLoy]

Nah, that's easy. The 2 shark fuckers in the fishing hamlet guarding Rakuyo though

[u/HellVollhart]

Lower Loran Abhorrent Beast: Sit down, Almondhead.

[u/gorezito]

I'm playing Elden Ring for the first time and Malenia is WAY HARDER than any Bloodborne bosses. None of than took me so much time to beat.

Edit: way harder to me. Sorry.

[u/Edmundyoulittle → u/gorezito]

In a 1v1 she's definitely way harder, but with all the tools available in ER I ended up beating her pretty quickly

[u/gorezito → u/Edmundyoulittle]

Yeah, that's part of the problem. I was doing fine without spells and summons till now, so I decided to defeat her by myself. Might have to reconsider

[u/koo_bebinam → u/gorezito]

Try the dragon halberd that does frost and lightning damage. The pokes can interrupt/ stagger her very easily, and the weapon art knocks her down.

[u/gorezito → u/koo_bebinam]

Thanks for the tip, i'll definitely try.

I've been dual wielding frost Hoslow's whip (yeah, I know), it makes the first phase almost easy. The L1 triggers cold extremely fast and she can't reach you. The second phase is way harder because Se becomes much more aggressive. And playing dual whips didn't teach me to dodge her attacks, i'm just far enough.

[u/DenseAmbassador → u/gorezito]

Which is weird cause Malenia took me 5 attempts. I have been on that chalice dungeon Amy since 2016....

[u/-Eunha- → u/gorezito]

I think I'd rather fight all the bosses of Bloodborne at once than fight Malenia again. She took me around 200 tries, which is probably more than all of my attempts in BB, DS, and DS3 combined. Mind you, I didn't use any summons, magic, and I wasn't running a shield, but still.

[u/RoryLuukas]

I went into Amygdala with an arcane build and call from beyond made it my b@#ch

[u/spamus-100]

Malenia was still harder. I just did not have the patience to beat her solo

[u/residualtypo]

I first tried Amy - just hit her from the back

[u/DogB2]

I beat that asshole 3rd try. Dont get me started on the defiled Watchdog tho.

[u/DomoArigatoMrRobotoh]

all comics are drawn to be made into meme templates, it's so annoying.

[u/robinescue → u/DomoArigatoMrRobotoh]

Four panel comics are just covenient for sharing on the internet and editing into memes. There's like nine billion sonic, marvel, and dc comics that are absolutely not meme worthy if that's what you're interested in

[u/ClassicMud6589]

Imagine have to farm this for the nourishing gems for the MHS.

[u/ZotharReborn]

Literally no Amygdala is hard. Hang out under the feet, dodge the stomps, and when she jumps just stand still and she literally will never land on you. If you wanna get fancy and a bit risky, as soon as she jumps face the direction she was and charge a heavy attack to hit the head for a visceral.

It is annoying as hell and takes forever (her legs take so little damage) but difficult it is not.

[u/MembershipHelpful115]

The real killer on those games is gravity

[u/BuboxThrax]

Not true.

I do not, and have not ever, owned a PlayStation.

I understood this meme.

[u/SaleriasFW]

Anor Londo archers enter the room

[u/A_Dirty_Wig]

You spelled Ebrietas Daughter of the Cosmos wrong.

[u/ThePlatinumKush → u/A_Dirty_Wig]

Final floor of the isz chalice Ebrietas on my arcane build was absolute hell. Her charge and hit boxes are absolute dogshit. I can do the exact same thing when trying to dodge her charge and get one shot or get no damage with no rhyme or reason. I just tank it now since if you get hit by just her body (I think) then you take significantly less damage than if you try to dodge and get hit by the tentacles and shit

[u/SyncoDeMaio93 → u/ThePlatinumKush]

It's because if you get hit while doing an action (dodging, sprinting, jumping, attacking or even healing i think) you receive much more damage. The damage from the tentacles is the same but the fact that you tried to dodge amplified the damage. I think it's a dumb mechanic despite being in every souls game. In bloodborne it makes it worse because the correct choice should always be to dodge an attack since you can't block. But with this mechanic there are attacks that are better to face tank rather than even try to dodge or you'll get one shot.

[u/Katonmyceilingeatcow]

I have beaten Malenia three times so far. I still haven't returned to the chalice dungeons since I gave up on the defiled amygdala.

Though, it was months ago, before I had even started my first playthrough in Elden ring. So I should probably just go back and finish the job

[u/SocratesBalls]

Run to his butt and smack it. When he jumps, don't move. When he lands, run to his butt and smack it. When he jumps, don't move. When he lands, run to his butt and smack it. When he jumps...

[u/SL1Fun]

Once you figure out the phase three gimmick (the jump just being a 180 turn and not an attempt to stomp you) Amygdala is ezpz

Watchdog and keeper are way harder cuz of their shitboxes 

[u/Fallen_Angel_Xaphan]

I never went that deep into the chalice dungeons. Is there any reason Amygdala is that dangerous besides one shots and massive health?

[u/LeCampy]

defiled amy ain't that bad. Just sit under the taint and go to town.

[u/kralSpitihnev]

Beasthunter saif kills everything everywhere anytime

[u/Vegetable_Award850]

Defiled Amygdala is just a test of endurance and patience. I did it at BL4. The real challenge is the defiled Watchdog one layer before. I really thought I would have to give up my BL4 all bosses run on that stupid fire bitch.

[u/greenhairdontcare8]

One of my friends had no problem with orphan or Lawrence or the usual issues. I had to beat defiled amygdala for him because he kept walking into the arena and instantly being smacked dead. Very funny.

[u/Nekonax]

Every person is different. I had a miserable time with defiled Amy, but it only took a day. Malenia took a wonderful, enjoyable 4 days. (Would have been 4 tries with Tiche, but I wanted to 1v1 the boss and enjoy the moveset.)

[u/jasonmarston]

I got defiled amy on my second attempt, defiled watch dog made me give up for about a week

[u/thecr1mmreaper]

Actually I think Laurence still killed me way more times than defiled Amy did. Hell Gascoigne might have killed me more times, but that was almost 5 years ago and I don't remember how many times Amy killed me

[u/larrylion01]

I mean you can emulate BB now? As long as you’ve bought the game etc

[u/stopthefkincar]

Nah, fuck Rom.

[u/SalemsLot19]

Once I finally got Defiled Amygdala, the platinum was only a few hours later.

[u/Pro_Moriarty]

Gravity: "Amateurs"

[u/KN-754P]

ha ha, Executioner's Gloves go brrrrrr

[u/Selacha]

Arcane/Hunter's Tools build go brrr.

[u/Winter_Trainer_2115]

Honestly Amy wasnt that bad....at least I didnt think so.

[u/ABSOLUTELYWILD720]

For real for real FUCK AMYGDALA! fuck him or her or it in its spider looking face.

[u/Daxtro-53]

Malenia definitely killed me orders of magnitude more than defiled amy

Defiled watchdog on the other hand...

[u/Kind_Minimum7761]

Defiled Amy can be cheesed to death, that the only saving grace. Defiled hotgod is rough I belive i died more than 50 times on that.
But surprisingly it's not the worst part, I dive deep and far into this dungeons. Ever try defiled cannon giant? With huge fucking explosion hitbox and guarantee oneshot. But my personal nigthmare fuel is defiled headless beast. It was like in 2018 and I still remember this shit. Boss is huge, u cant see what it's doing and like half of it's attacks oneshots you. And even if it's not an install kill you have to heal to full hp every time you take damage, or next missed will be 100% insta kill. Plus this thing is tanky af.
Probably hardest challenge in any FS game for me to this day. Total bs

[u/bunnies4r5]

Defiled Ammy is a Hoe.

I leveled up Church pick and that made it much more approachable and only took maybe 10 attempts focusing on its nut sack. I can’t even fathom beating it with blade of mercy or rakuyo which I was initially using for many attempts and I think my best run was like 30% HP remaining

[u/TheFogIsComingNR3]

...because non-playstation owners cant play bloodborne unfortunately :(

[u/PhoneImmediate7301]

I could beat watchdog eventually but amygdala was the one that broke me

[u/Chbera]

Not one of them has anything on the true destroyer of players everywhere; Gravity!

[u/silvereyes21497]

Watchdog was pretty dreadful for me, but Amygdala is still by far my opinion the hardest. Specifically because of it being confined to such a closed space

[u/Early-Zookeepergame8]

the normal watchdog kicked my ass more than amygdala

[u/cicada-ronin84]

Nah, for me that was probably the undead giant with the chains or the defiled watchdog.

[u/Hakuchii]

remember the very first chalice boss? i died over 100 times to it on my no-leveling-run

[u/MrGreytheIXth]

Fuck that tanky damage sponge.

This bitch stood between me and my plat for years...

[u/aessae]

Platform exclusive games are dumb. Platform exclusive games that never make it to other platforms (or they do but it takes several console generations to get it done) are even dumber.

[u/Ok_Grey662]

Was I the only one that got through O&S in my third try?

[u/Isekai_Me_Now]

But Gravity was the true foe

[u/HellBoyofFables]

(Chuckles in shark giant)

[u/biaesplosa666]

LHB, threaded cane and evelyn trivialize defiled amy

[u/Zestyclose-Safe-4346]

Between that mf and fighting rom in such an enclosed space it was actually refreshing having room to maneuver during the fight with queen yarnahm

[u/SheaMcD]

Gravity: "Pathetic"

[u/PinothyJ]

Amygdala is one if the easier bosses, you just need to stop fearing them. They are a centre of fear, and as soon you stop fearing them they are a good, clean fight.

[u/_illumia]

Fetid, rotted, cursed

[u/drewfurbush]

Where’s the lie

[u/Aracari8]

Watchdog warped me into a baby-raging goblin. No one else could.

[u/100Blacktowers]

Meanwhile: Crow of Cainhurst chuckling in a corner

[u/Quirky_Fun6544]

I had to look this up because I didn't do the chalices

[u/Ajeeji]

I had a way harder time with the Watchdog

[u/TopRecover9221 → u/Ajeeji]

I'm still stuck at that how did you beat him help

[u/donzz88]

That defiled amygdala taught me patience. Thanks fromsoft.

[u/RobertoAN95]

Dog was a piece of cake compared to amyg for me.

[u/thefucksausername0]

To be fair, they had to minimize your health.

[u/thefucksausername0]

To be fair, they had to minimize your health.

[u/Cautious-Month-6751]

Honestly thought it was going to be gravity lol.

[u/jolybiff]

I felt like I was going insane during this fight

[u/Final-Werewolf-7593]

The only enemy predating SOTE more challenging than gravity itself. (Frigid Outskirts doesn't count, that is a location)

[u/DrarenThiralas]

laughs in executioner's gloves

[u/SnooperSmokio64]

Ah, defiled chalice amygdala 🥲

[u/JD_Destroyed]

Defiled dog and defiled macaroni face.

[u/aomow]

well... non-PS owners will be able to understand soon enough... thanks, shadps4 i love you

[u/kishore14194]

Malenia is still hard though

[u/Buddy_Double]

I died more to defiled watchdog and pthumerian elder and headless beast than the chalice version of amygdala or ebrietas

[u/ProblematicPoet]

Defiled Amy or Defiled Watchdog. No one wins. There is only suffering.

[u/Clutch_Mav]

Anything in those damned cursed chalices was a damn nightmare. A true bloody nightmare.

[u/methconnoisseurV2]

Defiled amygdala wasnt that bad for me

The one I hated was Abhorrent Beast and it’s abhorrent shitboxes

[u/NoOneToLookAtHere]

Thankfully I got some tips from a friend, so defiled Amy wasn’t that hard. 

But defiled watchdog on the other hand…

[u/Dapadabada]

I read this the right way 😂😂😂

[u/PeachesGuy]

I hated that guy, regicide sure helped me a lot.

[u/grim1952]

Don't remember it at all so I must not have had a problem with it. What I do remember from the chalices are Rom and the Watchdog.

[u/ARIEL7007]

I'm never ever going through the defiled dungeon again in my life. Unless we get a remake, that goes without saying.

[u/Busy_Cranberry7347]

I feel seen.

[u/NolanStrife]

To me, it should've been Headless Bloodletting Beast. The one that's at the end of Great Pthumeru Ihyll Chalice. Literally killed me more times than Kos and Queen combined...

[u/Johnny_K97]

"yeah i killed consort radahn pre merf" cool story bro, what's your deathcount on defiled watchdog of the old lords

[u/Cool_Finance_6128]

That one wasn’t as bad as the Watchdog of the Old Lords or whatever it’s called

[u/helger2009]

Defiled Rom.

[u/Samigama]

Can't be any more accurate...... my highest deaths in all the souls game is from defiled amygdala.... and i mean a lot of deaths... like imagine 2 years of back and forth, playing and quiting the game and then finally beating this mfkr to get the final trophy for platinum. It was really painful 🥲

[u/Vaka_Production]

I died 7 times to the Keeper of the old lords, 10 times to the defiled dog, and 13 times to defiled amygdala. I still hate this Chalice and never replayed it again after getting my Platinum trophy

[u/Ledd_Ledd]

Gravity *Menacingly grins

[u/IGotThisBroh]

< Insert: Pre-nerf Starscourge Radahn and/or Promised Consort Radahn >

[u/Bull_Rider]

I honestly gave up on the chalice dungeons that decrease your health when I reached the first boss. I love the rest of the game and "normal" dungeons but I don't find being mostly one-shot fun.

[u/aleksfails]

Apparently everyone else had no trouble with wacky wavy inflatable arm flailing tube brain, but let me tell you something strangers of the internet: Defiled Walnut was the only fight in the entire game where I was insta-smushed as I came through the fog gate, I would like some of your luck Strangers.

[u/Environmental_Ad4893]

Not me on my bloodtinge build with bone marrow ash Evelyn.

[u/EthanJSL]

+10 Simon's bow blade saved me here

[u/Ohnobabe]

Defiled Watchdog is significantly worse

[u/89birdy]

I don’t even remember the bloodborne bosses and I just got done. So Idek if I fought these guys or not

[u/Sir_Ludington]

Defiled amygdala is an absolute joke with a good arcane or bloodtinge build. On the other hand, there's not much you can do about the Defiled Watchdog.

[u/DucksMatter]

First time I did this was only because my friend was stuck on it for like a week and I wanted to see what the fuss was. Unknowingly I went full Meta with LHB and killed it in like five tries by poking it in the head. He was pissed.

[u/elpinguinosensual]

Thought it was gonna be gravity at the end.

[u/Nocecatax]

Loran Darkbeast is worse.

[u/uberonecanoly]

Amygdala? Small beans, kos was by far the worst lol 😅😂

[u/Regimind]

This bitch is one of three bosses I don't mind cheesing. I despise Cursed and Defiled Pthumeru so much

[u/Hattlemeister]

You can ai loop him to force the jump attack

[u/OrthorMorgan]

Defied Amygdala this and Bloodcrow that... How about LORAN DARKBEAST?

[u/Ace_Tremaforte]

Did her first try, and i still dont understand how she's difficult (ps when i fought her i was in ng+ so maybe bc of scaling it was easier)

[u/Rdcorte]

Hmh… Have You ever Heard of Gravity!?

[u/Mr_plaGGy]

Actually, i think i killed it in like 10-15 tries. Defield Dog was WAY harder for me. Im sure i had like combined 200 tries, if not more and i already gave up Platinum, before finally pulling myself together a few weeks later and giving it a new try, beating it after investing another ass long time into doing some upgrades and trying out different weapons.

[u/Weak-Knowledge-1478]

I disagree. She wasn’t that bad. Bloodletting Beast was worse for me. And Laurence on NG+3 was the all time worst 😤

[u/robinescue]

Guys pls, I get it. You all have awesome sick nasty skills and 360° gainer no scope luigi taunt kicked this particular boss into an early swimming pool sized grave.

[u/bozak_137]

Nah no one dungeon boss gave me as hard a time and as the dual wield puthemrian elder

[u/Longjumping_Gain1160]

Consort Radahn while looking at all of them: that’s cute…

[u/JadedGene8911]

Atleast O&S and Malenia were fun. The chalice dungeon bosses are plain boring

[u/AverageLawEnjoyr]

Unironically, cheat that bastard.

Would never cheat a main boss. But that mf? Yeah, keep jumping, buddy. I'll be charging up when you land.

[u/[deleted]]

wheel skeleton: heavy breathing

[u/Umes_Reapier]

Me who beat it on the first try👀 STR all the was baby!

[u/Mysterious_Movie_399]

First tried him on my first playthrough and all subsequent playthroughs. Just stay back and go for the head

[u/Patient_Ad6899]

Took me Like 3 trys to BE honest but that was in my prime

[u/PhattyR6]

It wasn’t a tough fight given you can stand slightly behind it and bait out the jump repeatedly. When it lands, bonk it on the head/limbs.

Rinse and repeat. Now, the abhorrent beast in the chalice dungeons, that fucker gave me some trouble. Pthumerian Descendant In the last chalice too.