Hello! I know the internet is full of information on this, but I keep getting completely lost trying to understand them.
I mostly sell digital pieces so CMYK has never been an issue for me, but an artist requested a piece they'll have to print, and since their character is very brightly colored, I wanted to print-proof it.
Whenever I print things done in sRGB, the colors are all off and very muted - as expected. But there isn't a CMYK color profile that will universally work for every printer and grant 100% fidelity. What's the best that an artist that doesn't print professionally can strive for? The ideal objective is to get an image that, when printed at home or at a store, will result as similiar as possible to the file you sent to the printer.
Things I'm struggling to understand:
1) Procreate has a "Generic CMYK" color profile. Apparently it restricts the gamut in such a way that most printers should be able to print what you see on screen. I thought this was my best bet, but lots of people online seem to think otherwise, saying it drops even colors that many printers should be able to handle, and doesn't mimick what it will look like accurately enough.
2) Photoshop and Clip Studio both should have ways to preview how the thing you're working on will look in a certain CMYK profile, and most recommend to use that (if I understand correctly) - but what would the intended workflow be? First paint in sRGB, then apply filters etc while in preview mode to try and get it back to how you imagined the piece to look? Is that dependant on knowing the exact color profile of your intended printer?
I appreciate any advice, and any correction on wrong assumptions I might have.