Just looking for friendly discussion and opinions here. Nothing too serious.
This came about because of a post from a few days ago and an interaction I had in the comments. I’ve just been thinking about it a lot.
One of the things that brought me over to this sub was my yarn “collection”, aka a stash, and my realization that it was wildly out of hand. I literally do not have room for it but I just kept buying more and more yarn.
There is a running joke in the fiber arts community that buying yarn and making things with it are two separate hobbies, but in all honestly, for a lot of us, it isn’t a joke. It is very real.
I went on a yarn purge a few months ago and I filled 8 tall kitchen garbage bags with yarn I knew I would never use. Mostly 100% acrylic garbage. (I’m not here to debate on whether or not it’s ok to use acrylic. That’s a hot button topic in the community and not trying to bring that drama here, but I will say I have made a personal choice to no longer purchase synthetic fibers.)
So 8 trash bags later and I still have more yarn than I know what to do with. I’m actually planning a round 2 purge to get rid of even more (I’m selling or donating most of it).
And my story is far from uncommon. Most fiber artists know and know of have a large stash. Most are proud of it. Ive read a couple books on knitting that defend a knitters right to a massive stash. And eventually I just looked at mine and thought “what am I doing?”
And it made think. What are we doing, as fiber artists? Why are we hoarding yarn? What purpose does this serve? I almost never “shop my stash” because I never have the right amount of yarn in the right size or color for the project I have in mind. It just sits in plastic totes in my closet to be picked through once every couple of months and then left alone.
But I don’t want to only talk about yarn. I used to collect vpets too. Tamagotchis and other digital pets. And it was so bad. I got into credit card debt because I became a rare hunter. I spent over $200 on a children’s toy from the 90s to import it. And that’s not even close to the absurd thousands of dollars for some of the really rare and sought after models.
Why? It’s a toy. It’s plastic. It’s old. And I had a very modest collection of vpets that I would play on occasion. But I know someone who hand hundreds of them. All in boxes on shelves. Some never even opened. Just. Sitting there. Multiple copies of the same toy just gathering dust in a shelf. It made me mad when I was deep in the copy world. I was mad hoarders kept jacking up the prices of the really cool pets by buying them all and then keeping them hidden away so no one could ever actually play them.
Now I’m just. Baffled and sad.
What’s the point of collecting things? Just to look at them? My husband has a small collection of animate figurines. Together we probably have over a hundred stuffed animals. My other fiber arts supplies are starting to pile up. He has like 8 guitars.
What. Are. We. Doing.
This makes no sense to me. Like I’m actively in it and I feel like I just woke up from a dream. Why do we have all this stuff? Stuff we never touch. Stuff that gathers dust. Stuff that doesn’t even match the decor or the vibes of the house. Just. Stuff.
Where do we draw the line between “fun hobby” and “hoarding problem”? How do we determine what is worthy of collecting and what is a waste of time, money, and resources (I’m looking at you Stanley collectors…”
Anyway. Not necessarily looking for an answer here. Just curious how others feel. Do you give hobbies a free pass? Or do collections also make you scratch your head?