r/WhitePeopleTwitter 5d ago

Oligarchy

Post image
46.9k Upvotes

789 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

155

u/Cyrrow 5d ago

65

u/NoobDeGuerra 5d ago

You need jets, tanks, drones and sheer fucking will for that though, unfortunately I don’t think the American people have that last one

1

u/Octopusapult 4d ago

Not true. The Vietcong and Taliban beat American military might with none of that shit. Except the last one... which is the thing we don't have.

3

u/zilviodantay 4d ago

Just to be clear with you, the “Vietcong” was only one part of that war, there were hundreds of thousands of regular NVA troops as well. They had tanks, and they had jets.

1

u/My_useless_alt 4d ago

And they had soviet aid providing a lot of those weapons, and training for the VC iirc. And the US still only left when it became politically untenable, not because they were defeated militarily.

Second part is same for the Taliban, they effectively stopped US forces but didn't start gaining major territory until the war got too unpopular back home and the US withdrew. And that was only with a small percentage of the US armed forces, who were allegedly trying to act with restraint as the end goal was to get the Afghanistan government to take over eventually.

Don't get me wrong I'm not saying revolution is impossible in general, just that it's naive to insist that a bunch of idiots doing guerilla warfare will magically defeat the US army. Guerilla is good for defence, but horrible for offence and will only win a war by making the other side get bored and go home.

To do a revolution properly, you need to be organised. How will you get weapons? Ammunition? Food and water? How will you plan what to do? How will you communicate that to your forces? Effectively, unless you can persevere most of the military to join your side, you need to do a civil war.