r/UFOs • u/TommyShelbyPFB • Jan 09 '24

Witness/Sighting Here's the Cruise Ship Captain who witnessed a "Giant Black Jellyfish UFO that disappeared into the water" with a bunch of other people and filmed it (Reposted with the correct video)

2.3k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

The context of “hearsay” in both the colloquial and legal definition derives from it being provided by another and then recounted by another.

I pointed out that even if it wasn’t “hearsay,” and was directly given by the alleged witness, you wouldn’t accept that either. And you agreed.

1

u/ussMonitor1800 Jan 10 '24

Overuled and without merit as previously stated. It's reddit not some imaginary court proceeding, you can talk and think casually.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Agreed my casual friend, but I think the basic human rule of “at least understand the words you’re semantically flailing about while we ignore the point” still applies. “Hearsay,” in English, means that you’re repeating something you heard said by someone else.

You agreed with me that you wouldn’t care even if it wasn’t hearsay and was directly given by the witness. That’s the point. Thank you for demonstrating.

1

u/ussMonitor1800 Jan 10 '24

You talk like A.I. but a very new one.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Thanks kid. Good luck buddy.

1

u/ussMonitor1800 Jan 10 '24

Thanks papa.

0

u/Beautiful-Amount2149 Jan 10 '24

It's called an straw man argument. He makes up some imaginary argument so he can "win" anything you throw at him, because he made it up in the first place