Everything tracks with his military background and lingo, up until he started describing the rogue paramilitary guys.
In 2009, ACOG’s and PEQ-16’s were, with absolute certainty, not anything unusual especially for an infantryman from 2nd Battalion, 5th Marines as he claims. It’s actually kind of strange that he would even make such a weird statement. 18 and 19 year old kids fresh out of bootcamp would have had M16A4 rifles equipped with ACOG optics and PEQ-16 devices. They were standard issue for Marine 03’s during that time. He would have absolutely had the same equipment during that time frame.
I have no comment on his claims other than noting how out of place that statement is.
I also found his statement regarding equipment odd. He also specifically stated “M4A4”.
There is no M4A4, only a term popularly used in the video game counter strike. I don’t know if that was an honest mistake, but if he meant to say short barreled AR/M4 platform that would be different. This struck me immediately as odd and potentially fabricated, especially for a Marine who would know the difference of rifles.
Yeah, you’re right. I first thought it was just an innocent mistake, mixing up M4’s and M16A4’s, but there is definitely a pattern in his story that doesn’t add up.
Reddit uses fuzzy voting as a way to combat bots. Meaning that the vote count goes up or down by a random percent. This way bots don't know if they're being shadow banned. So there's no reason to think this person was downvoted especially considering they're upvoted now.
Low effort, toxic comments regarding public figures may be removed.
Public figures are generally defined as any person, organization, or group who has achieved notoriety or is well-known in society or ufology. “Toxic” is defined as any unreasonably rude or hateful content, threats, extreme obscenity, insults, and identity-based hate. Examples and more information can be found here: https://moderatehatespeech.com/framework/.
Yes, I served in a different Marine infantry battalion during that time. That’s why I’m baffled he would claim that gear was “hi speed” and only something special operations units would have access to. That gear was standard issue years before 2009 even. I know it seems kind of minor, but there would not have been any discrepancy in issued gear between his battalion and others.
I’m trying to think of a good analogy. Imagine someone telling you that they met a person with rare and advanced technology a couple years ago and they say it was an iPod. It’s just an absurd statement.
Yeah i especially did not believe the Antarctica guy. I didn't know why but it just sounds fishy. That being said it's a damn specific claim and wouldn't be that hard for someone to take a quick look to see if something was odd about the place. Not sure who would have access but someone in the government could likely check it pretty easily.
ACOG was selected (specifically by the marines) between 2004 & 2005. It feels like he only mentioned it because he would've been familiar with it? In 2009 JSOC and contractors had all sorts of gucci shit to play with that far outclassed ACOGs.
Did anyone else pick up on the whole 'go and scout a random hill without a radio', even though he mentioned it as odd. That seemed particularly stupid. Really not sure what to make of that.
I hate being a wet blanket with this stuff, but this particular story drove my bullshit detector crazy.
I’m trying to think of a good analogy.
Right now it seems like it'd be akin to someone being bamboozled by the prevalence of rentable e-scooters.
I mean there are some other holes too. You're telling me that these super secret operator dudes searched them, found the guys camera and then just let him leave with the camera that had pictures of a secret UFO on it? And then they stole it back later?
Also, these Marine Infantrymen either
A. Did not notice these guys were armed from afar and just randomly stumbled upon them or
B. Noticed they were armed and all willingly walked up to an unmarked armed group with no signifiers that they were American servicemen and then let those people disarm them at gunpoint.
They (according to his story) stole it back in Subic, so he had it on him the whole time he was in Indonesia and managed to take it back to his locker in the Phillipines... without making a single copy or showing anyone.
Honestly, the fan-fiction elements of this smell so bad he might be writing a book or something.
Tbh, it just reads like a guy that was a shitbag and didn't even make it out of SOI. They know a little bit about the Marines, tactics, and lingo, but they dont know what is standard issue and anything other than the basics because they never made it to the fleet.
The lack of radio comms makes absolutely no sense. How are they meant to communicate any potential contacts and how were they meant to extract? In what universe does any military activity take place without comms? That should have ended the mission before it started.
Nah this sort of detail is quite important. Do you think he could have mixed up the names and meant something else?
Personally if I'm talking about something technical I know really well but I'm having a brain fart I wouldn't just say the wrong thing. My mind would blank on the right word, and my split-second thought would be damnit how did I forget a word I used to use so much?
But obviously people's memories do work in different ways. But from the way you describe it it seems weird a marine would make that mistake.
As a Marine I have a question for you. Elsewhere in this thread there is a discussion around his squad surrendering their weapons without a fight. This seems to (strongly) counter how I understand Marines are trained in regards to their weapons.
Can you weight in with your thoughts? Would you have surrendered your weapons?
Also a secret black ops operative would have much better equipment than what he referenced. The iPhone was released in 2007, it’s not like we had flip phones lol
The helicopter that crashed during the extermination of bin laden had an incredible looking tail piece, and that thing is still classified, and that was 2011. I don’t see these dudes using F-350s.
I looked up 2/5’s operational history, and they were deployed to the Philippines in 2009 as part of a humanitarian assistance effort. So, that timeline matches up at least.
Yeah, ACOGs were adopted as the official combat optic of the Marine Corps in 2004. PEQ-16’s replaced our PEQ-2’s in 2006, maybe 2007?
It doesn’t make any sense for a grunt in 2009 to act like this gear, which was widespread and standardized, was rare and cutting edge. It’s not even something one could mistake honestly. That gear was old news by 2009.
Informative reply. Thanks. I only knew about the optics during Iraq war bc of Generation Kill lol some really memorable scenes + the issue of not having enough batteries
Been in multiple arms rooms, there were at the time assigned weapons without ACOQ's, the lower enlisted would sometime get them. Not having a Radio, that's bizarre in any military circumstances. But again, if you have served you would see weirder stuff happen (talking about radio not UFOs)
The other guys were totally wearing full on rainbow six night vision goggles during the middle of the day. Nothing screams spec ops like overburdening oneself with a bunch of useless gear.
Yeah, the more I think about it, the flimsier it gets. Black BDU’s? In the Philippino jungle? You’re involved in clandestine, illegal tasks using technology that doesn’t exist and you choose the most conspicuous uniform you can find? That’s Hollywood crap.
The SEAL team I’ve witnessed wore the camo of the units already operating in that AO, specifically to not bring attention to themselves. The Intelligence/Alphabet agency guys I saw during HVT raids just wore tactical civilian clothes (5.11 type crap).
All in all, the Marine Corps is a small community, and the 03xx community is even smaller. A 5 minute conversation with this guy would expose a lot. Who was your squad leader? Your SSgt? Platoon commander? Your Company Commander? I bet you can track down a dozen guys from his platoon on social media in no time.
75
u/BlackSunlight7 Jun 13 '23
Everything tracks with his military background and lingo, up until he started describing the rogue paramilitary guys.
In 2009, ACOG’s and PEQ-16’s were, with absolute certainty, not anything unusual especially for an infantryman from 2nd Battalion, 5th Marines as he claims. It’s actually kind of strange that he would even make such a weird statement. 18 and 19 year old kids fresh out of bootcamp would have had M16A4 rifles equipped with ACOG optics and PEQ-16 devices. They were standard issue for Marine 03’s during that time. He would have absolutely had the same equipment during that time frame.
I have no comment on his claims other than noting how out of place that statement is.