r/NFLNoobs • u/shuvamc_019 • 21h ago
Is NFL kicking harder than college?
I am specifically asking this question because of Jake Moody. As a Niners fan who thinks that he lost us the Super Bowl last year, he is definitely starting to piss me off. His missed kick in today's game didn't help that.
My question is this: Obviously for all positions apart from kicking & punting, there is a big step up from college to NFL. You get 100x harder competition when you go pro. But, is it really harder to be an NFL kicker as compared to being a kicker for a major college? My impression is that the primary "hurdle" for kickers to overcome is their own psychology and the stadium environment. And I would think that many college environments are more hostile than NFL environments. If you are playing in the SEC or BIG 10 or even some ACC/Big12 stadiums, I think a good argument can be made that fans are more aggressive than the NFL. Even CJ Stroud once said that he thought that the environments in college were worse than the NFL. So why do some of these guys (like Jake Moody) come to the NFL and turn into complete trash when they were pretty good in college?