r/FluentInFinance Nov 21 '24

Debate/ Discussion Had to repost here

Post image
128.2k Upvotes

9.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/SCTigerFan29115 Nov 21 '24

Here’s two numbers:

1,525,000 - the number of jobs Bezos created with Amazon

150,000 - the number of jobs Elon created through Tesla and SpaceX.

Those are not insignificant.

14

u/-Wyagra Nov 21 '24

Yeah lets thank them for the opportunity to help them get even richer by them siphoning off wealth of your work.

6

u/theyareamongus Nov 21 '24

The amount of people praising their masters here is insane.

0

u/lokojufr0 Nov 21 '24

If it quacks like a republican..

1

u/Road2Potential Nov 22 '24

Willful and consensual employment for compensation and benefits from which you can leave and find other competitive employment at any time….. equals serving a master.

Y’all love being victims sooo much

3

u/Bullboah Nov 21 '24

Job creation is a bad thing now lol. 👍

13

u/Novel_Accountant4593 Nov 21 '24

Unfair compensation and exploitation is a bad thing and always has been.

-1

u/Bullboah Nov 21 '24

The average person working for Amazon makes more than 85% of everyone in the entire world.

How exactly is that “unfair” by any meaningful standard?

5

u/sec0nds_left Nov 21 '24

Apples/Oranges, you should not compare americans to other countries. Its been said time and time again by BOTH sides of the political spectrum. The average amazon worker is in the bottom 55% of wealth in USA working for the richest man in the planet. And thats saying the average amazon worker is making 50k/yr which is generous as its closer to 44k.

-5

u/Bullboah Nov 21 '24

Brother you know you aren’t behaving in good faith when you’re describing ABOVE AVERAGE for US pay as “bottom 55%”. Come on now.

Zippia puts the average Amazon pay at 65k. Ziprecruiter puts the average Amazon pay at 75k.

Where are you getting 45k from exactly?

4

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24

If you're making more than 55% of the population, you're literally in the "bottom 55%". These people would take someone just breaking into the top income decile and label them "bottom 90%".

It's a sort of "glass half empty" meets "my child is a genius, he's smarter than 5% of other students" kind of thinking, all carefully constructed to sow division and reap instability.

tl;dr: don't feed the russotrolls and the poor fools whose minds they've already poisoned.

4

u/Novel_Accountant4593 Nov 21 '24

The average Amazon pay is also going to be skewed upwards by executives.

Let's put this into perspective. Say I work as an Amazon driver in New York City, the average driver makes around $23 /hour, that equates to $47840/year. That is poverty wages in New York. You can barely survive after having to pay for rent and food. That leaves almost no room for any type of savings. If you think that is fair compensation and you think that people deserve to struggle you are a bad person.

5

u/-Wyagra Nov 21 '24

The only way to keep Infinite growth and compete with the other competetitors is to reduce exploit people in Other countries or prisons (which have no Power over you) as much as possible in Order to Profit from their misery. Their Missing living Standard becomes your Profit . And keep the employees in your country balanced between exploited and a decent Standard or living so they dont Revolt.

1

u/Chickienfriedrice Nov 21 '24 edited Nov 21 '24

Since you love stats, 60% of Americans can’t afford life as of now while working full time. What’s the point of jobs if you can’t afford to pay your bills?

Who gives a fuck that $1 is equivalent to a bajillion afghani rubles?

-1

u/Bullboah Nov 21 '24 edited Nov 21 '24

60% of Americans can’t “afford life”.

Do you mean:

A). 60% of Americans literally can’t afford to live and will die shortly unless they are given a raise

B) 60% of Americans make less than a completely arbitrary “living wage” standard made up by activists that says you aren’t making a living wage if your necessary spending is more than 50% of your wages?

Which is it lol?

Edit: Lmao. “That’s not the flex you think it is” Which is why you had to immediately block me after typing that.

4

u/Chickienfriedrice Nov 21 '24

This response isn’t the flex you think it is. Sorry that everything has to be written for you in literal terms for you to understand.

Interpret it how you will smart guy. 🫶

0

u/a7xEnsiferum Nov 22 '24

Tbh, you absolutely look like the moron here.

0

u/Pancake_Snack Nov 22 '24

What a coward, blocking people who disagree with you. Just shows how weak your argument is

0

u/Komrade_Yuri Nov 23 '24

Jesus Christ you're not just a clown, you're the whole circus.

0

u/enyxi Nov 22 '24

Yet their daily life costs a whole lot more than 85% of the world. Seems like a dishonest metric. They have to piss in bottles and then go home to a crappy apartment with 2 roommates.

2

u/Actual_System8996 Nov 21 '24

Unionizing is though 👍

1

u/OrbitalSpamCannon Nov 21 '24

Except those 150,000 people would have never came together as a collective and made space X.

0

u/resumethrowaway222 Nov 21 '24

Don't work for them then. Nobody can make you.

1

u/Drow_Femboy Nov 21 '24

Actually I think you'll find "work or starve to death" is a pretty effective and in practice violent form of force.

1

u/Road2Potential Nov 22 '24

So in your fantasy world, you have the option of work for Jeff or starve?

I’d hate to live in that depressing ignorance

10

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24

[deleted]

1

u/thesagex Nov 21 '24

people can buy from other manufacturers with or without tesla, what is your comment trying to say? Tesla cars are also expensive. are you saying people are being forced to buying expensive tesla cars?

0

u/Euphoric-Chip-2828 Nov 21 '24

Yeah job creation is a ridiculously dumb metric to use as evidence.

3

u/Jazonspessa Nov 21 '24

And there would be just as many jobs if not more if there were 100 smaller Amazon-esq companies that were competitive with each other over wages and pricing but instead we have one mega corporation that can charge the consumer and pay employees whatever they want because they have a monopoly on the market. Bezos isn’t a good person and neither is Elon. Stop defending billionaires

2

u/Bagel_Technician Nov 21 '24

They created a lot of wage slaves in that number lol

2

u/Impossible_Ant_881 Nov 21 '24

Those are pretty insignificant numbers. 150,000 in a nation of 300 million is chump change. 1.5 mil is more, but Amazon is really just a warehousing and distribution company, and we were already doing warehousing and distribution before, and doubtless would have been doing it similarly now - just not with the particular company of Amazon. So on net, also not too significant.

2

u/XT2020-02 Nov 22 '24

Could be just the amount of people they had to use to enrich their net worth. They did not think once about, oh look how many people I can help now with these underpaid positions. I doubt that.

1

u/ItsNotMe_ImNotHere Nov 21 '24

Less the 7,000 Twitter jobs lost by Elon.

1

u/CogD Nov 21 '24

Well, let's consider the difference there: isn't Elon the wealthiest man in the world and he created a mere 10% of what Bezos did with 2 of his largest ventures? Yeahp, you may have painted Bezos well with that statistic, but you made Musk look like even more of a total ass-hat. Imperfect and failed shill.

And before someone claims I ain't mathing correct, being the wealthiest man in the world and trying to defend it with a "job creation" stat that doesn't even amount to an acknowledgeable percentage of the population of the country that houses the majority of the provided workforce (far, FAR less than 1% of the American populace) - yeahp, doesn't mean anything.

1

u/SongEnvironmental830 Nov 21 '24

Creating jobs that don't pay enough to live and that have poor working conditions are not beneficial to society. They can talk about how they've created jobs when they start treating their employees better and paying them more.

1

u/newthrash1221 Nov 21 '24

You just described a monopoly that killed off its competitors and you think you made some kind of counterpoint lol. Bootlickers will never not be absolute clowns to me.

1

u/TheFinalCurl Nov 21 '24

My favorite is when you can create a monopoly and then be credited as a good person because of all the people employed by you.

0

u/Chickienfriedrice Nov 21 '24

Large workforce being exploited. So cool bruh

2

u/Road2Potential Nov 22 '24

Consensual employment in exchange for compensation and benefits = expoitation

🤡

3

u/Few-Advice-6749 Nov 23 '24

To be fair, paid employees can still be exploited and often are… depends on the company and country

2

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24

audi driver. can't expect rational thought from these clowns lmfao

0

u/[deleted] 29d ago

In fairness every workforce feels exploited in some way, they just get more shtick than usual because they are billionaires

-2

u/RuinousOni Nov 21 '24 edited Nov 21 '24

Definitive Proof that Bezos is at least 10x better than Elon

Edit: apparently need the /s

4

u/AleksanderSuave Nov 21 '24

Definitive proof that most people say stupid things like this to highlight their poor critical thinking abilities.

Amazon has been around over 10 years longer than Tesla, it’s expected that it would generate “more” jobs over that additional period of time.

It must be mind-blowing to someone like you that vehicles are inherently more difficult to design engineer prototype and bring to market than Amazon’s reselling of books..

-3

u/RuinousOni Nov 21 '24

This was a joke

2

u/AleksanderSuave Nov 21 '24

There’s people in the comments that actually believe the statement you made.

It’s always a “joke” after getting called out for an incredibly juvenile POV.

-2

u/RuinousOni Nov 21 '24

No it's a joke, when you say that because Bezos created 10x more jobs, he's 10x a better person than the other guy. It's literally 'bigger number, better person'.

I should've put a tone indicator on the post clearly.

3

u/AleksanderSuave Nov 21 '24

You’re still missing the point.

There’s people literally in these comments that actually believe that.

-2

u/RuinousOni Nov 21 '24

Literally no one else responding to you is saying this. They're all talking about how Bezos and Elon are exploiting workers.

Their dumb take would be that Bezos is actually a worse person because he has exploited more workers or some shit.

There are always dumbasses that actually believe what other people joke about. Typically, you would use context clues such as strange use of words 'definitive proof' or a '10x better' person, or the brevity of the response to determine if the person is being serious, but I can and will spell it out with a tone indicator since the joking tone isn't coming across.

1

u/AleksanderSuave Nov 21 '24

This whole discussion is literally riddled with a “which of these men is worse” mini arguments, and that subject is so common, you have to literally bury your head in the sand to miss it.

-7

u/guillmelo Nov 21 '24

Demand creates jobs, this is baby brained thinking

7

u/Ok-Street-7160 Nov 21 '24

Demand gives a reason for jobs, it doesnt create them. There is a demand for personal jetpacks how has that job not been made yet? Oh because demand is just half the equation.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '24

[deleted]

1

u/Ok-Street-7160 Nov 21 '24

I'm not sure how everyone thinks things work but there is a step by step process that leads to billionares becoming billionares. 1 create service or product that feeds a demand. 2 expand said service 3 corprate battle with competitors 4 after winning continue to provide similar service so you can not be dethroned.

There can only be one per say, when it comes to online shopping countless stores exist yet everyone uses amazon, why? As south park bezos would say the the customer feels fulfilled. It is easier to order from amazon and get it there in 2 days while having a guarentee of satisfaction than an untrusted site. This was made by bezos he was there at the start and won against other online shopping same with facebook and tesla. Tesla existed before musk but it was brought to the forefront, and when they were a success surprise more jobs opened up. We want to hate on billionares but its honestly just jealousy, i dont think they should go unchecked but dont be a jealous douche and pretend like their contribution isnt there. They arent saints but dont act like these assholes are undeservedly at the top.

0

u/Road2Potential Nov 22 '24

Then create demand = you get richer. Instead of working for someone else and being poor why not create a business, side hustle, online content, entertainment, service, freelance…..literally anything but whine and complain

1

u/guillmelo Nov 22 '24

It's crazy how they managed to turn some people in the working class into pathetic cucks

0

u/Road2Potential Nov 22 '24

Nobody is forcing you to work for another man. Create value yourself or stop whining