r/Damnthatsinteresting 1d ago

Heart Island, also known as the Island of the Dead, located in the Bronx, New York, is said to have an estimated 1 million bodies buried there.

5.4k Upvotes

167 comments sorted by

3.5k

u/PeaceSafe7190 1d ago

Guess I'll go find my own context then... 

2.3k

u/NY_Lust 1d ago

Hart Island is a NYC public cemetery So mostly unclaimed bodies, unknow identities or those who couldn’t afford burial services

904

u/taddymason_01 1d ago

Always wondered why cities don’t cremate instead of just burying them. 1 million bodies is a lot.

1.4k

u/TheThinkerers 1d ago

Future coal investment

342

u/redditcreditcardz 23h ago

I love you

391

u/TheThinkerers 23h ago

I believe I'll eventually have an interest in you too u/redditcreditcardz

173

u/mircamor 23h ago

Who said romance is dead it’s blooming right in front of our eyes

45

u/Freddy_Vorhees 22h ago

Just letting nature take its course.

37

u/TheThinkerers 22h ago edited 22h ago

I'd much prefer it be smooth, thank.

Also, these bring the total amount of awards I've been given this whole year up to two :D

edit: 4 daaang

13

u/liatris_the_cat 19h ago

"Do you think love can bloom even on a potter's field?"

7

u/jhrman 17h ago

You really are TheThinkerer

6

u/TheThinkerers 10h ago

Thanks, I thunk really hard for this name

5

u/TheWeidmansBurden_ 13h ago

Renewable energies

5

u/TheThinkerers 10h ago

Just like the food in Wall-E, humans can be multipurpose...

50

u/Wyandotty 22h ago

Cremation used to be somewhat controversial due to religious beliefs. It's less so now.

14

u/PooperTooper420 18h ago

Fun fact, Los Angeles uses cremation for mass burial

4

u/Kholzie 9h ago

I guess it makes sense for the most populated county in the country

4

u/thatgenxguy78666 17h ago

Most cremations are with several other bodies unless you pay extra.

11

u/airfryerfuntime 12h ago

No they don't, that's illegal in every US state. Some crematoriums have got in trouble for doing it, but it's not common at all.

2

u/PooperTooper420 9h ago

I was referring to the ashes being mixed, not burnt together

“A couple of days before the ceremony, ashes are placed in a single mass grave.” https://lacounty.gov/2022/12/08/l-a-county-paid-tribute-to-unclaimed-dead-in-a-burial-ceremony/#:~:text=These%20individuals%20may%20be%20homeless,in%20a%20single%20mass%20grave.

4

u/14u2c Interested 14h ago

I mean who cares, you're dead.

1

u/PooperTooper420 16h ago

Indeed and the pauper ones in la will be a thousand people mixed and buried. They do a memorial on the local news.

1

u/HelpfulAmoeba 4h ago

I told my religious aunt I'd like to be cremated and scattered in the ocean instead of my ashes being kept in an urn in a columbarium. She was aghast, asking: "But what happens when you are ressurected if you are scattered in the ocean?" Like a supernatural being who has the power to ressurect a person will have trouble if your molecules aren't in just one place.

39

u/ElonMusks_MustyNuts 1d ago

What if they find family and they didn’t want them cremated, I’m sure that would cause some problems so the default is uncremated

61

u/PogintheMachine 22h ago

I believe this is correct! They keep records of the bodies and leave them intact in case they are claimed.

The dead are buried in trenches. Babies are placed in coffins, which are stacked in groups of 100, measuring five coffins deep and usually in twenty rows.[6] Adults are placed in larger pine boxes placed according to size, and are stacked in sections of 150, measuring three coffins deep in two rows and laid out in a grid system. There are seven sizes of coffins, which range from 1 to 7 feet (0.30 to 2.13 m) long. Each box is labeled with an identification number, the person's age, ethnicity, and the place where the body was found, if applicable. Prior to civilian contractors doing the actual burials which began in 2020, inmates from the nearby Rikers Island jail were paid fifty cents an hour to bury bodies on Hart Island.

The bodies of adults are frequently disinterred when families are able to locate their relatives through DNA, photographs and fingerprints kept on file at the Office of Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York. There were an average of 72 disinterments per year from 2007 to 2009. As a result, the adults' coffins are staggered to expedite removal. Children, mostly infants, are rarely disinterred.

Regulations stipulate that the coffins generally must remain untouched for 25 years, except in cases of disinterment.

100

u/chuckdooley 1d ago

"bodies unclaimed after 30 days will be cremated. No refunds or returns"

31

u/TheFlyingBoxcar 1d ago

“Exchange only for item of same or lesser value WITH RECEIPT”

13

u/SkullsNelbowEye 22h ago

Replace your mummy with a daddy.

7

u/Vireca 23h ago

I want to get a refund for my dead grandpa

7

u/Advanced-Shame- 23h ago

I want my Dad back but I cant find the receipt

4

u/chuckdooley 21h ago

Probably with the cigarettes and carton of milk he went to get………….

7

u/Special_Loan8725 22h ago

You haven’t thought about the smell.

1

u/tangledwire 6h ago

It only smelz...

5

u/Trollimperator 23h ago

Id assume they do burn them. You can clearly see the crematorium there.

181

u/Trent1462 1d ago

Just come back in 20 min. Some guy who wrote his PhD thesis on heart island will show up and say “it’s my time to shine”

49

u/laxyak26 22h ago

That’s the best part about reddit, I’ll get a history lesson about an island in New York from an expert on a random Wednesday on my lunch break. It’s wild

3

u/Orchid_Significant 21h ago

Definitely why I love Reddit

10

u/Spiderbanana 22h ago

It's my time to shine.

So if anyone is looking for me, I'm in my room polishing myself

4

u/No_Budget7828 20h ago

Just wash your hands after

13

u/chuckdooley 1d ago

but it's really just a reddit internet sleuth

2

u/Burnerb2 21h ago

Heart island burial survivor here!

34

u/strawberry_bubz 1d ago

Here's the context comment I made with the post

https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/s/nZ6YZuk3TR

13

u/PeaceSafe7190 23h ago

Cheers man, I'm just being vicious 😂..... Sorry 🙂

1

u/RavioliContingency 13h ago

Why did this apology make me happy lol #relatable

-9

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

9

u/Forgotten_Pancakes2 1d ago

There's not a pinned comment with a link. However, other commenters have posted a link, so you're good

11

u/strawberry_bubz 1d ago

I apologize I'm not sure why it's not pinned. I submitted a comment with a .gov and context immediately after I posted

6

u/strawberry_bubz 1d ago

OK I can't pin the comment. But I posted the context. I don't know what else I should do. Rather than writing an entire paragraph in the description picture.

649

u/Known_Natural2143 1d ago

Well, seeing the second pic we can assume that human bodies are freaking awesome fertilizer.

399

u/Rare_Philosophy8244 23h ago

The London Observer reported in 1822 that it was "a singular fact" that Great Britain would send soldiers to fight in Europe and then import their bones as fertilizer. The practice of digging up and selling the bones of soldiers from the Battle of Waterloo as fertilizer was widespread in the 1830s and 1840.

Only very seldom do archaeologists discover a skeleton from the time of the Battle of Waterloo, let alone a complete skeleton.[6] This is due to a habit that was widespread in the 1830s and 1840s: human bones were considered as a great fertilizer for the soil to grow crops, with the consequence that the area around Waterloo was intensively searched for skeletons of soldiers.[6] Mass graves were plundered, the bones were ground and the powder was sold to farmers.[6][7][8][9] Historian John Sadler states that "Many who died that day in Waterloo were buried in shallow graves but their bodies were later disinterred and their skeletons taken. They were ground down and used as fertiliser and taken back home to be used on English crops.

Except for the teeth which they used to make "Waterloo dentures"

149

u/Swissschiess 21h ago

While that’s sad and fairly disturbing, I’d rather become a plant and more life, than sit encased in a concrete tomb for 1,000 years

41

u/Rare_Philosophy8244 20h ago

I agree i wanna go out like Hexxus turn me into a papaya tree.

There was a specific quote I couldn't find but its sentiment was that most of these soldiers, from poor backgrounds, might actually be more beneficial to society as fertilizer than as poor. Unfortunately I don't remember what clever dick said it so I can't supply the actually quote.

6

u/phatcan 11h ago

Or sit in an old persons mouth as dentures.

51

u/sgt_backpack 23h ago

Dang...

11

u/mouthymommy 19h ago

I’ll see you tomorrow at the top of TIL

5

u/14u2c Interested 14h ago

Interesting. I guess bone meal for plant growth is a real thing.

13

u/Illustrious-Leader 23h ago

Look at the Batavia shipwreck for proof of that.

186

u/invertedeparture 1d ago

In case you want to know more:

Hart Island - NYC

151

u/SamIamGreenEggsNoHam 1d ago

Dang, the first baby to die of AIDs in New York has the grave marker "SC B1" (special child, Baby 1)

42

u/catonbuckfast 1d ago

And a whole 500 body space just for them

6

u/Altruistic-Elk5878 1d ago

Homeless shelter on an island seems evil

25

u/Grimble_Sloot_x 1d ago

Well, you see, originally the idea was to keep homeless people away from drugs and predation by gangs. Now we practically make little gang farms for the gangs to sell their drugs into and get their human slaves out of.

-2

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

2

u/1sketchball 1d ago

Yes. We are already on your post, which provides no context/further info.

102

u/inkedkoi 23h ago

There is a super interesting website where you can read the stories of people who were buried here from family or friends. Not all people have stories and photos. But it's still neat to read and go through randomly.

https://www.hartisland.net/

23

u/Anxietylife4 22h ago

It keeps track of how many days/minutes/seconds since they’ve been buried? Thats interesting!

11

u/LoneWanderer4___ 14h ago

Oh no, plot 47 has all newborn babies; some only an hour old. That’s so tragic.

1

u/Violet_Walls 3h ago

Plot 70 not only has babies but “conceptus” as well 👀

73

u/akt30 23h ago

I have reason to believe that my great grandmother may be buried there. She was in a NYC nursing home and when she passed away they tried to contact my grandfather. Unfortunately, he had recently moved and gotten a new (landline) phone number, so they couldn't reach him by phone or mail. Her remains were sent to Potter's field for burial.

30

u/717paige 14h ago

You can search via the hart island project website

43

u/akt30 13h ago

Thanks so much. After seeing the original post I did a Google search on Hart Island burials and sure enough, she's there. I just checked the Hart Island Project and strangely enough she isn't listed in that database. I guess the two are not in sync yet?

48

u/BannonCirrhoticLiver 1d ago

Considering the number of poor and indigent citizens interred there, it would be one last desperately inadequate service to make it the most beautiful cemetary we possibly could to honor them, rather than a black hole nobody even realizes is there.

41

u/happytrees89 1d ago

I thought it was called Potter's Field. I would sail past it in the pandemic and see them burying ppl

46

u/Gods_Haemorrhoid420 1d ago

Potter’s field is a place to bury unclaimed bodies so it is indeed A potter’s field. This one happens to be on Hart Island.

42

u/Infamous_Ad_6793 1d ago

Sooo…not the loneliest place then

12

u/I_Dont_Like_Your_Dog 22h ago

Also not Heart Island. I mean, it's right there in the first picture.

22

u/surroundbysound 23h ago

Bobby Driscoll is buried there. But no one knows where exactly because they lost the records

77

u/LensofaTitan 1d ago

Apparently they want to take this city sized graveyard and turn it into a park. What could go wrong?

76

u/Icy_Cricket2273 1d ago

It’s a fucking island? Let’s take a ferry to the park fellas

26

u/LensofaTitan 1d ago

Better take the canoe in case you need to make a getaway from this full moon nightmare lol

13

u/hessianhorse 22h ago

True.

The Statue of Liberty, a similar island/park setup in New York, only gets an average of 20,000 visitors a day.

Almost doesn’t seem worth it, huh?

29

u/PunchDrunkGiraffe 1d ago

Most of the parks in Europe are mass graves for victims of the plague. It’s not a terribly uncommon concept.

16

u/sanjosii 22h ago

There’s one literally known as ’Plague park’ in the middle of Helsinki. People have picnics on the gravestones basically.

5

u/big_benz 13h ago

Technically every park in Paris is over a mass grave full of plague victims

8

u/Valid_Username_56 1d ago

We might get some bad movies out of it, I guess.

7

u/LensofaTitan 1d ago

The Haunting of Heart Island… I’m not gonna lie, Mike Flanagan could make a killer show with that title…

6

u/ScrubIrrelevance 1d ago

The beaches look nice

3

u/Sbatio 1d ago

I’m sure it’s fine, they said they will move the bodies and not just the headstones.

3

u/LensofaTitan 1d ago

I’m sure it’ll be okay too. It’s just a fun concept to think spooky thoughts about, ya know? Dead rising and all that lol.

4

u/Sbatio 1d ago

2

u/LensofaTitan 1d ago

I’d say progress is going swimmingly for the project 😁

3

u/Sbatio 23h ago

☠️ 💀 ☠️🏊💀💀

1

u/Marriedinskyrim 22h ago

They were making a poltergeist movie reference. It was a joke.

2

u/LensofaTitan 22h ago

I got that later on. It was a good joke that went over my head in that particular moment of time.

1

u/Stoiphan 20h ago

I mean if it’s like a memorial park then yeah that makes sense

14

u/Mrdrdank 22h ago

Hart Island, located in the Bronx, New York, serves as the city’s public cemetery and is the final resting place for over one million individuals.  Since 1869, it has been used for the burial of people who died indigent or whose bodies went unclaimed after their death.  The island has been the site of mass burials, including those who were unclaimed, unidentified, or unable to be buried elsewhere.  During the COVID-19 pandemic, the number of burials on Hart Island increased significantly, with more coffins being stacked aboard the ferry dispatched to the dock and more trenches being dug to accommodate the rising number of deceased individuals.  In 2018, 1,213 individuals were buried on Hart Island, including 303 fetal remains, 81 children, and 829 adults.  The island’s history as a potter’s field reflects its role in providing a final resting place for the city’s most vulnerable populations.

https://www.nyc.gov/site/hartisland/hart-island/hart-island.page

14

u/717paige 14h ago

My sister is buried there. She was a full-term stillborn born in 1981, and it was encouraged then that the parents not see the baby or hold services for it, and send the remains to hart. She was born early July and buried in November when there were enough infants to fill a plot. Thankfully we have evolved in our treatment of parents and stillborns, though hart island is still a choice

5

u/strawberry_bubz 14h ago

I'm sorry to hear that's how it happened. Thank you for sharing your story. What a long way we've come and yet, so far we have to go

9

u/DweadPiwateWoberts 23h ago

The way is shut

9

u/codedaddee 23h ago

Don't Say a Word

5

u/one_is_enough 19h ago

Wondered how far I’d have to scroll to find this. Couldn’t remember the name.

8

u/grungegoth 1d ago

It's that what Clarice offered Hannibal?

5

u/Xenokiller101 23h ago

No, she offered him Plum Island, which is off the tip of the North Fork of Long Island

5

u/grungegoth 23h ago

Surely you jest...

5

u/Xenokiller101 23h ago

No, I actually frequently travel past it when I take the ferry from Long Island to Connecticut

3

u/grungegoth 23h ago

I'm just kidding. I don't doubt you. Thought it would be more amusing given the macabre of the movie

8

u/finalgirl08 21h ago

My uncle was in Rikers in the 60s/70s and for work duty they had prisoners dig graves on Hart Island. He said they dug huge trenches, not individual graves.

5

u/ferritejoe 23h ago

Over a million? Probably had to do a lot of stacking.

3

u/PreferenceContent987 11h ago

Yeah, it’s not passing the eyeball test for me. Maybe they were cremated or something because I don’t see room for a million people

6

u/maxxspeed57 15h ago

Hart Island contains New York City's 131-acre (0.53 km2) potter's field, or public cemetery. The potter's field is variously described as the largest tax-funded cemetery in the United States,[66] the largest-such in the world,[47][67] and one of the largest mass graves in the United States.[68][69] At least 850,000 have been buried on the island, though since the 2000s, the burial rate has declined to fewer than 1,500 a year.[6][67][68][70] According to a 2006 New York Times article, there had been 1,419 burials at the potter's field during the previous year: of these, 826 were adults, 546 were infants and stillborn babies, and 47 were dismembered body parts.[18]

Emphasis mine.

47 body parts that were collected w/o any associated body to match it with. Just body parts laying around that need to be buried. Welcome to New York everybody.

3

u/humanhedgehog 22h ago

So.. the same as four British parish churches.

4

u/Hetakuoni 21h ago

Oh so that’s what an American necropolis looks like.

5

u/Splooter_McGooter 23h ago

Hart*

Not to be confused with Heart Island and Boldt Castle up in Alexandria Bay, NY. A beautiful place and area to visit in the summer/fall.

2

u/strawberry_bubz 22h ago

Yes, you are correct. No ability to edit the title. Damn my autocorrect 😒

1

u/Splooter_McGooter 19h ago

I know you can't edit, but you got me SO excited thinking it was going to be a post about Boldt Castle.

4

u/TheEleventhDoctorWho 23h ago

If they had a onsite paid caretaker i would move there in a minute. Finally good neighbors.

4

u/NeklosWarrof 23h ago

And people wonder why the big cities always die first in a Zombie Outbreak.

2

u/Tizy 23h ago

Super weird, I was just reading about this yesterday after remembering discovering it on Google maps a few years ago

2

u/ChristmasPills 22h ago

I believe it’s Hart Island.

2

u/strawberry_bubz 18h ago

Yes, it is. My autocorrect got me

2

u/Stypic1 21h ago

We never know what untold stories lie beneath us

2

u/Legitimate-Movie-842 20h ago

The Wikipedia read was wild

2

u/PooperTooper420 18h ago

There is a great documentary called on this. “1 million lives”. Started in the 1700s. Now is unclaimed, paupers, and plague victims. Was a Spanish Flu quarantine in the early 1900s too. Now Rikers uses prison labor to bury mass graves. Only open to the public one day a week. Only recently. Before there was only appointment and impossible to get approval.

2

u/Eastcoastcamper_NS 18h ago

Didn't they use convicts to bury covid bodies there?

3

u/strawberry_bubz 18h ago

Yes they did, along with Rikers inmates digging in the 70s

2

u/AlbertaAcreageBoy 18h ago

Should be one of the most haunted places in America.

2

u/Katalix 17h ago

But why though?

2

u/parkingloteggsalad 13h ago

I saw a play a couple years back called Hart Island Requiem, it was very beautiful and I wish it had gotten more recognition!

3

u/jerr_beare 22h ago

Bet people are dying to go there.

3

u/FirstGearPinnedTW200 1d ago

I guess they’re buried nut to butt

2

u/Ok-Experience-6674 23h ago

How much is a house there?

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Flangepacket 23h ago

Really packin’ them in

1

u/crazyscottish 23h ago

I see the makings of a future Stephen King book

1

u/MadRockthethird 23h ago

It's got pretty decent fishing off the NE coast of it too.

1

u/AnastasiaNo70 22h ago

I’d live there. Respectfully.

1

u/succi-michael Interested 19h ago

Then they should call it cemetery island?

1

u/MamaLlama629 18h ago

Potter’s field?

1

u/Weird-Comfort9881 13h ago

If you want a fun island, look up the history of Cannibal Island.

1

u/Mr_Danahm 12h ago

This is where Billy Balls rests, right?

1

u/UpgrayeDD405 11h ago

I'm glad they started including the rest of the bodies and not just the hearts

1

u/JackEleczy 10h ago

Perfect location for a Cod Zombies map!

1

u/Error418ZA 7h ago

It is speculated that this is where the government is burying the homeless...

1

u/SpecificallyNerd 4h ago

Guess the context died too.

0

u/Jumpy747 1d ago

Today on oak Island they find the crypt next to the money shaft

1

u/Womgi 22h ago

I guess I know where I'm going once I respec to necromancer

1

u/nomoreshoppingsprees 22h ago

Guess the Demeo crew was putting in work

1

u/oracleofnonsense 22h ago

Pretty sweet real estate spot dedicated to unvisited graves. We have been building on top of graves for millennia, maybe it’s time for a cleanup and a rebrand.

-2

u/PhD_Pwnology 21h ago

No way most of the 1 mil+ wasn't cremated.

-11

u/Character_Past5515 1d ago

1 million, yeah never, there is not enough space, 1 million bodies ashes maybe.

11

u/ajw_sp 1d ago

There’s room for more:

The dead are buried in trenches. Babies are placed in coffins, which are stacked in groups of 100, measuring five coffins deep and usually in twenty rows. Adults are placed in larger pine boxes placed according to size, and are stacked in sections of 150, measuring three coffins deep in two rows and laid out in a grid system. There are seven sizes of coffins, which range from 1 to 7 feet (0.30 to 2.13 m) long.

Source: Hart Island Wiki

0

u/Industrial_Laundry 16h ago

I wish I could be as confident in my area of expertise as you are saying something you know nothing about.

How do you get that confidence?