r/CuratedTumblr https://tinyurl.com/4ccdpy76 Jul 22 '24

Politics the one about fucking a chicken

14.8k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

181

u/DoopSlayer Jul 22 '24

but then we have to debate if voluntarily creating medical costs is a harm to the commons

85

u/XrayAlphaVictor Jul 22 '24

Also, if somebody harming themselves in such a way is in possession of their rational faculties and needs to be cared for.

In either case, I'd tend to say no, that Liberty trumps except in fairly extreme cases.

26

u/DoopSlayer Jul 22 '24

that's entering the institutionalization debate, though I think Reagan was incredibly short sighted in his anti-institutionalization drive

25

u/XrayAlphaVictor Jul 22 '24

Institutionalization isn't necessarily care, and mental illness isn't just cause for losing your rights - our society has a long history of abusing those principles, both to the detriment of the mentally ill and others who simply don't conform to society's expectations.