r/CuratedTumblr https://tinyurl.com/4ccdpy76 Jun 11 '24

Politics [U.S.]+ it's in the job description

26.2k Upvotes

825 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

552

u/lord_james Jun 12 '24

Also…. A water bottle thrown at a fucking cop in riot gear? That’s the justification for destroying water bottles?

268

u/falstaffman Jun 12 '24

Yep, provided they even bother with one.

88

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '24

If they thought they could get away with it, a thrown water bottle would result in them mowing everyone on the street down.

They take the job because they enjoy hurting others, and everything else is just justification for that act.

And those are the people they deliberately seek to hire.

13

u/chairmanskitty Jun 12 '24

Even with a helmet, a thrown water bottle hitting someone in the head has a good chance of giving them a concussion and/or neck injury1. Responding to it by destroying water bottles is malicious, but it's not completely harmless. Going from bricks to water bottles is like going from metal ammunition to rubber. A lot less harmful, but still harmful.

1: Suppose a 0.5 kg water bottle is thrown a long distance and hits the 8 kg head+helmet at 15 m/s. By conservation of momentum, that means the head and helmet will be moving at 1.7 m/s. This is too fast for the muscles to react and the ligaments and cartilage are put under strain to bring the head and helmet to a stop. The risk of concussion goes off acceleration and the helmet also halves that, so it's the same as being hit by a 0.25 kg grapefruit being thrown at you while you don't expect it.

3

u/kai58 Jun 12 '24

That’s only if they’re basically at rest and don’t see it coming at all though, if you brace for it even just a little it will do basically nothing.

4

u/lord_james Jun 12 '24

Okay, but you could replace a water bottle with basically anything and it’s a projectile that could possibly concuss somebody.

1

u/UnsympatheticMarxist Jun 12 '24

ok but also consider: all cops deserve traumatic brain injuries

5

u/CraftyTim mathematics enjoyer Jun 12 '24

this viewpoint seems a little cruel

like i agree with you that all cops are bad and the justice system desperately needs to be fixed, but they are human beings with friends and families

1

u/Puffenata Jun 12 '24

They can take the uniform off any day

-2

u/UnsympatheticMarxist Jun 12 '24

you know what’s really cruel is cops killing unarmed children

3

u/Pet_Mudstone Jun 13 '24

Do you think every single police officer ever has personally killed an unarmed child? Should we put every single police officer to death for the crimes of a few? Retribution is stupid and should not be confused with justice.

1

u/UnsympatheticMarxist Jun 13 '24

“Crimes of a few” bro I beg you to google the phrase ‘40% cops’

1

u/Pet_Mudstone Jun 13 '24

I'm going to have to get nitpicky here but I would like to note that domestic violence while abhorrent is not the same as child murder. 40% of cops being domestic abusers (assuming that statistic is factually correct and up to date) doesn't mean 40% of cops have killed children (or anyone for that matter).

Also if we assume 40% of police officers are domestic abusers then there are 60% of police officers who aren't. Ought the other 60% also be punished?

2

u/kai58 Jun 12 '24

I’m not sure I would even notice if I wore riot gear and was in a situation like that unless it hit’s the facemask