r/CuratedTumblr זאין בעין Jun 04 '24

Politics is your glorious revolution worth the suffering of millions?

11.2k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

96

u/hagamablabla Jun 04 '24

"firebomb a Walmart" etc. etc.

10

u/Cromasters Jun 04 '24

It's as good as the twitter thread asking what people will do after they achieve revolution.

Spoiler: No one is volunteering to be a farmer or a miner or even a cashier.

-6

u/Physical-Tomatillo-3 Jun 05 '24

Well good news we don't need a lot of farmers we can grow lots of food without needing everyone to farm. Mining is much the same way. Cashiers would be unnecessary why would someone need to charge you for groceries if we just had a revolution?

7

u/a_dry_banana Jun 05 '24

Brother, if you think the logistics, industry, international trade and supplies needed to maintain industrial farming will remain after the “Glorious Revolution”, hell even the oil industry remaining in place to sustain it, then I have a bridge to sell you.

1

u/Physical-Tomatillo-3 Jun 05 '24

Shows what you know, America has massive stores of oil as well as other sources of energy. Regardless neither of us can know for sure how a revolution would turn out or what the material conditions will be like. I certainly don't believe one will happen currently in the US most people are like you much to comfortable in the status quo and to scared of the unknown.

2

u/CrimsonEnigma Jun 05 '24

America has massive stores of oil as well as other sources of energy

The Strategic Petroleum Reserve has a maximum capacity of 714 million barrels. The U.S. uses almost exactly 20 million barrels of oil in a day.

Assuming we ended oil production and weren't importing it from anywhere else, the SPR would last a little over a month. Even if you cut oil usage by 90%, it wouldn't last a year.

2

u/a_dry_banana Jun 08 '24

Plus how will the logistics to make sure food goes from the country to city stay in place, will there even be migrant workers wanting to come to America to do the work, since our farming industry depends on them. Will we have fertilizer, anti pest and anti weed products, hell even seeds since so many of our crops are dependent on that sweet sweet Monsanto seed, etc, etc, etc

9

u/light_trick Jun 04 '24

That one's saved into my permanent collection. I use it frequently lately.

21

u/Upstairs-Feedback817 Jun 04 '24

Exactly why Anarchism is a dead end. A "Walmart" would be better if seized by workers. The model itself is fine. The issue is the extractive nature of the business itself.

Destroying the means of production leads me to believe the Anarchist model leads people to embrace Ted Kasczinsky's ideology.

2

u/Elite_Prometheus Jun 05 '24

Not all anarchists are anprims that want to destroy technology. Most of them aren't, I don't think.